jimmy blue shoes
Well-Known Member
Rammyblues said:Apologies, and this is from someone who has never sent a text by mobile phone in my life, in fact I don't own a mobile phone.
Rammyblues said:Apologies, and this is from someone who has never sent a text by mobile phone in my life, in fact I don't own a mobile phone.
Didsbury Dave said:schfc6 said:I personally dont see United signing him. For years their fans have hit us with insults about us signing the likes of Cole and Cooke or Peter City.
I think signing De Jong would be a clear indication of how far they've fallen.
First it was Vidal at £40+ million, then Strooman, Khedera, Kroos they've been linked with some of Europe's best central midfield players.
They end up with a (and I like De Jong as much as anyone) but in all honesty a City reject whom we have significantly improved up on.
It's a massive admission of their status if they sign a player we sold due to his limitations..
I can categorically reassure you that their manager won't give a hoot who a player used to play for if he improves their team. If he did he'd be an idiot.
schfc6 said:Didsbury Dave said:schfc6 said:I personally dont see United signing him. For years their fans have hit us with insults about us signing the likes of Cole and Cooke or Peter City.
I think signing De Jong would be a clear indication of how far they've fallen.
First it was Vidal at £40+ million, then Strooman, Khedera, Kroos they've been linked with some of Europe's best central midfield players.
They end up with a (and I like De Jong as much as anyone) but in all honesty a City reject whom we have significantly improved up on.
It's a massive admission of their status if they sign a player we sold due to his limitations..
I can categorically reassure you that their manager won't give a hoot who a player used to play for if he improves their team. If he did he'd be an idiot.
I'm sorry, but you can't categorically reassure me of anything. So far United have signed two players they identified 12 months ago. There is no sign of Van Gaal signing anyone.
The season starts in ten days, and they are now just being linked with anyone.
Football clubs don't just buy players because the manager wants them. Even if LVG wanted De Jong, United have to first consider their public perception. Signing a 30 year old City reject will hardly sell season tickets. It will hardly raise share prices.
It certainly won't be the 'United way'.
Can you honestly expect Woodward to boast about having millions to spend and pitch up with a cut price and limited ex City player?
If united had already signed a couple of very good and talented midfielders, I grant you Van Gaal may want a face he can rely on.
But not currently. Not in my opinion.
I for one, hope they sign De Jong. His best years are behind him, his reputation in England is that of a thug(despite having a very good record cards wise). I simply can't imagine one United fan being happy signing him.
They are full of self importane and arrogance, signing our cast offs would not go down well. Especially if their midfield is Fletcher, Carrick and De Jong. Obviously not countinh Herrera as I don't personally know anything about him.
schfc6 said:Didsbury Dave said:schfc6 said:I personally dont see United signing him. For years their fans have hit us with insults about us signing the likes of Cole and Cooke or Peter City.
I think signing De Jong would be a clear indication of how far they've fallen.
First it was Vidal at £40+ million, then Strooman, Khedera, Kroos they've been linked with some of Europe's best central midfield players.
They end up with a (and I like De Jong as much as anyone) but in all honesty a City reject whom we have significantly improved up on.
It's a massive admission of their status if they sign a player we sold due to his limitations..
I can categorically reassure you that their manager won't give a hoot who a player used to play for if he improves their team. If he did he'd be an idiot.
I'm sorry, but you can't categorically reassure me of anything. So far United have signed two players they identified 12 months ago. There is no sign of Van Gaal signing anyone.
The season starts in ten days, and they are now just being linked with anyone.
Football clubs don't just buy players because the manager wants them. Even if LVG wanted De Jong, United have to first consider their public perception. Signing a 30 year old City reject will hardly sell season tickets. It will hardly raise share prices.
It certainly won't be the 'United way'.
Can you honestly expect Woodward to boast about having millions to spend and pitch up with a cut price and limited ex City player?
If united had already signed a couple of very good and talented midfielders, I grant you Van Gaal may want a face he can rely on.
But not currently. Not in my opinion.
I for one, hope they sign De Jong. His best years are behind him, his reputation in England is that of a thug(despite having a very good record cards wise). I simply can't imagine one United fan being happy signing him.
They are full of self importane and arrogance, signing our cast offs would not go down well. Especially if their midfield is Fletcher, Carrick and De Jong. Obviously not countinh Herrera as I don't personally know anything about him.
Didsbury Dave said:schfc6 said:Didsbury Dave said:I can categorically reassure you that their manager won't give a hoot who a player used to play for if he improves their team. If he did he'd be an idiot.
I'm sorry, but you can't categorically reassure me of anything. So far United have signed two players they identified 12 months ago. There is no sign of Van Gaal signing anyone.
The season starts in ten days, and they are now just being linked with anyone.
Football clubs don't just buy players because the manager wants them. Even if LVG wanted De Jong, United have to first consider their public perception. Signing a 30 year old City reject will hardly sell season tickets. It will hardly raise share prices.
It certainly won't be the 'United way'.
Can you honestly expect Woodward to boast about having millions to spend and pitch up with a cut price and limited ex City player?
If united had already signed a couple of very good and talented midfielders, I grant you Van Gaal may want a face he can rely on.
But not currently. Not in my opinion.
I for one, hope they sign De Jong. His best years are behind him, his reputation in England is that of a thug(despite having a very good record cards wise). I simply can't imagine one United fan being happy signing him.
They are full of self importane and arrogance, signing our cast offs would not go down well. Especially if their midfield is Fletcher, Carrick and De Jong. Obviously not countinh Herrera as I don't personally know anything about him.
That's not the point I'm making. Whether they are identified by the board, the manager, whoever, doesn't matter. What I'm saying is that as a club it won't matter a jot whether a player three years ago played for City or anyone else. They'll sign him because they think he will improve them.
They would be blinkered lunatics to do anything else.
Would de Jong improve them? Probably, because their midfield is awful. He wouldn't be good enough for us any more because his passing range and ability on the ball isn't good enough for the Pellegrini style.