I can't really argue with that PC but I have a different perspective if our interest in him is real.
Firstly I'd be happy with a Phillips plus cash deal as imo he offers a lot move than Kalvin could, plus we stop a potential rival strengthening in the process. One in one out. Kalvin gets regular game time at WHU.
As you say Phil will likely be more pivotal in the centre next season and I think that's the part where we benefit as I believe he can be that tempo setting, creative force you mention next to Rodders, or Stones or in another scenario Rice adding a bit of steel. We'd still have one or two, maybe both of Gundo and Bernie to choose from and it looks like Kovacic is on his way too.
If Gundo and/or Bernie leave we'll have someone to replace either lined up. If the reports are true we'll also have McAtee and maybe Bobb learning the ropes and gaining experience with the first team squad. Both are better in the central area from the times I seen them so far. I haven't even included KDB in the equation.
Stones being able to give Rodders a rest is a fair shout. He's been immense in that role. Gvardiol coming in covers the loss of Eric and he looks very capable and as versatile as Johnny has been.
So where does Rice fit in ?
Cost aside, IMO he's the best option around to strengthen us even further in that central mid and defensive area. Pep likes versatility and he can cover both. He's got a great engine on him, will add legs to the midfield and we'll have multiple options in the event of injuries in both areas of the pitch. I also be flabbergasted if Pep doesn't improve him and bring out qualities that we've not seen before.
He's only 24 with the temperament of a player much older. I wouldn't like to see him at one of our rivals.
