Demichelis

[Neville Kneville]

He looks very good, although he takes too many chances for my liking, I like row Z defenders when any danger about

He has several hopeless lumps upfield, a pass straight to Real's midfield & several crappy headers straight to the opposition in that clip also.

If Pellegrini rates him then I'll trust him.

 

[ashytheblue]

if he's that consistent then that'll do for me!

 

[Neville Kneville]

impressive indeed...

Much Much more mobile than Lescott.

I'm more mobile than Lescott!

Define 'mobile'.

I keep reading this word & I recon none of you have got a clue what you mean when you use it.

There is nothing 'mobile' about anything in that clip. Describe to me, what the difference is that you see between what he does & what people such as Lescott don't do.

 

[toffee balls]

Looked good in the ill fated Dortmund game but unfortunately gifted them a lifeline in the game.

 

[tjmill]

Have to say am not a big fan of his and think there is better out there cant see this one happening

 

[Mickeylad]

To me he just looks more comfortable on the ball, doesn't seem to panic. I'm only going of that clip mind. But I can't think of a player in the team who is less comfortable on the ball than Lescott.

 

[Neville Kneville]

Looked good in the ill fated Dortmund game but unfortunately gifted them a lifeline in the game.

I thought the whole Malaga defence was shocking in that game.

 

[Eric Wirral]

Much Much more mobile than Lescott.

I'm more mobile than Lescott!

Define 'mobile'.

I keep reading this word & I recon none of you have got a clue what you mean when you use it.

There is nothing 'mobile' about anything in that clip. Describe to me, what the difference is that you see between what he does & what people such as Lescott don't do.

In that clip, he takes the ball earlier and moves away from danger more quickly.
More 'Mobile'

definition of MOBILE - 'Capable of moving or changing quickly from one state or condition to another'

 

[Neville Kneville]

I'm more mobile than Lescott!

Define 'mobile'.

I keep reading this word & I recon none of you have got a clue what you mean when you use it.

There is nothing 'mobile' about anything in that clip. Describe to me, what the difference is that you see between what he does & what people such as Lescott don't do.

In that clip, he takes the ball earlier and moves away from danger more quickly.
More 'Mobile'

definition of MOBILE - 'Capable of moving or changing quickly from one state or condition to another'

Well, no he doesn't do either of those things. He just does exactly what Lescott or even Johhny Evans or any typical centre back does. You could show a similar highlights reel from almost any game, even when Savic was playing for us. There is absolutely no difference whatsoever. In fact on two occasions, he gets stuck on the ball surrounded by Real players and almost loses it. That isn't 'moving away from danger' it's causing danger by being slow on the ball, the absolute opposite of 'mobile'. Other times he lumps the ball down field aimlessly. When he comes forward he is slow & ponderous moving the ball, all the stuff Lescott is slagged for, Richard Dunne could do absolutely anything Demichelis does on that clip, & on another day, would get caught in possession and cost a goal, exactly as he was very very lucky to avoid doing in that clip.

As I said, many people are just using the word 'mobile' without any relevance to what they are looking at.

 

[Neville Kneville]

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07u7zAzJonA[/youtube]

Stop the picture on 4:11. Have a look at the position taken up by our possible signing. Then have a look at his 'mobility' in dealing with Benzema.


Like I say, if Pellegrini thinks he's the man then fair enough, but he's no more 'mobile' or anything else, than the players we have now, & less 'mobile' than Kolo Toure.