Discuss Pellegrini (Pt 4)

[franksinatra]

I have every respect for doubters who express their doubts, but have the grace to come back on here and congratulate the manager on a good win and further add to what is after all a perfectly valid discussion (even if I find it boring) , what I can't be doing with is those that spout off during the hard times but disappear when we win it's almost as if they want us to lose in order to prove a point

Im a doubter but ive been happy to praise the performance today and the tactics of Pellegrini similarly I will criticise if I see something wrong. On the other foot its laughable that those defending Pellegrini, use the absence of Kompany or bad luck as justification for an away defeat but of course never use Kompanys absence for 12 games as a mitigating factor last year. Lack of balance on both sides by some.

 

[barryo]

You can stick your pelligrini up your a**e

I ashahamedly sang that at wembley before the Wigan game.

I now know different and need to apologise !!!

 

[Bluesiam]

Re: You can stick your pelligrini up your a**e

I ashahamedly sang that at wembley before the Wigan game.

I now know different and need to apologise !!!

Fair u turn mate.

BTW. I think there's a song there, to the tune of Aya, aye, yippy.......

 

[franksinatra]

Good post Marv,i too am confident had Kompany been an ever present this season,we'd be flying and probably sitting pretty at the top.

I'll say again,some daft fvckers will be embarrassed by their comments in this thread come the end of the season.

Similarly Kompany missed 12 league games last season. Im confident we would have won the league if he had been ever present. Still it never stopped some criticising Mancini and you for one have never used it as a mitigating factor for the problems last season. Why can arguments not be balanced? Pellegrini is being judged just like Mancini was last year.

Mancini would never have his sides keeping their feet on the gas like Pellers does. The other major difference is that Pellers will never be sacked because he is demotivating the team and criticising players in public.

Mate I lost count of the number of times we scored last minute goals under Mancini. We put two in at Old Trafford in injury time or Spurs away. No problem with criticising players Pellergrini did with Joe Hart. Incidentally Dzeko sounds pretty demotivated at the minute. It is called balance.

Anyway I have no interest in debating it. Chuffed with the team today and the tactics of the manager using Navas against a weak Spurs left back. If others want to use it to slight a previous manager or vindicate their view that is up to them.

 

[Blue Haze]

Good post Marv,i too am confident had Kompany been an ever present this season,we'd be flying and probably sitting pretty at the top.

I'll say again,some daft fvckers will be embarrassed by their comments in this thread come the end of the season.

Similarly Kompany missed 12 league games last season. Im confident we would have won the league if he had been ever present. Still it never stopped some criticising Mancini and you for one have never used it as a mitigating factor for the problems last season. Why can arguments not be balanced? Pellegrini is being judged just like Mancini was last year.

Mancini would never have his sides keeping their feet on the gas like Pellers does. The other major difference is that Pellers will never be sacked because he is demotivating the team and criticising players in public.

Exactly.

Pelle won't spend millions on players he won't use just for the sake of filling the roster. Demichelis was an alternative to Pepe not because he was roster filler like Sinclair, but because Pellegrini has an honest intention to make valuable use of him.

 

[Bluesiam]

Similarly Kompany missed 12 league games last season. Im confident we would have won the league if he had been ever present. Still it never stopped some criticising Mancini and you for one have never used it as a mitigating factor for the problems last season. Why can arguments not be balanced? Pellegrini is being judged just like Mancini was last year.

Mancini would never have his sides keeping their feet on the gas like Pellers does. The other major difference is that Pellers will never be sacked because he is demotivating the team and criticising players in public.

Mate I lost count of the number of times we scored last minute goals under Mancini. We put two in at Old Trafford in injury time or Spurs away. No problem with criticising players Pellergrini did with Joe Hart. Incidentally Dzeko sounds pretty demotivated at the minute. It is called balance.

Anyway I have no interest in debating it. Chuffed with the team today and the tactics of the manager using Navas against a weak Spurs left back. If others want to use it to slight a previous manager or vindicate their view that is up to them.

I didn't mean to slight our last Manager, just celebrate where we are going and counter criticism. We were winners under Mancini, and I am eternally grateful to him for what he did for our club. But I don't believe his method was sustainable and criticising players publicly was one of the reasons. My guess is he will improve on this aspect of his Management

 

[franksinatra]

Mancini would never have his sides keeping their feet on the gas like Pellers does. The other major difference is that Pellers will never be sacked because he is demotivating the team and criticising players in public.

Mate I lost count of the number of times we scored last minute goals under Mancini. We put two in at Old Trafford in injury time or Spurs away. No problem with criticising players Pellergrini did with Joe Hart. Incidentally Dzeko sounds pretty demotivated at the minute. It is called balance.

Anyway I have no interest in debating it. Chuffed with the team today and the tactics of the manager using Navas against a weak Spurs left back. If others want to use it to slight a previous manager or vindicate their view that is up to them.

I didn't mean to slight our last Manager, just celebrate where we are going and counter criticism. We were winners under Mancini, and I am eternally grateful to him for what he did for our club. But I don't believe his method was sustainable and criticising players publicly was one of the reasons. My guess is he will improve on this aspect of his Management

Nothing wrong with being excited about the future and we have seen many positives already under MPS reign. The argument whether his methods are sustainable is a valid one and I supopose we will never really find out. Be interesting to see if over time Pellegrini criticises players publicly and I have already cited his Joe Hart comments. For me it is no big issue criticising players in public, however the form of Nasri suggest I could be wrong about that one. Similarly there are a lot of people criticising Pellegrinis treatment of Joe Hart so its swing and roundabouts really.

 

[Exeter Blue I am here]

I have every respect for doubters who express their doubts, but have the grace to come back on here and congratulate the manager on a good win and further add to what is after all a perfectly valid discussion (even if I find it boring) , what I can't be doing with is those that spout off during the hard times but disappear when we win it's almost as if they want us to lose in order to prove a point

Im a doubter but ive been happy to praise the performance today and the tactics of Pellegrini similarly I will criticise if I see something wrong. On the other foot its laughable that those defending Pellegrini, use the absence of Kompany or bad luck as justification for an away defeat but of course never use Kompanys absence for 12 games as a mitigating factor last year. Lack of balance on both sides by some.

Give it a rest eh. There was some unbelievable nonsense being spouted on here last night, and there's been a pretty concerted effort so far from a few posters, not to fling some of it back where it came from. Why stir it all up again after a performance like that, when we're all playing nice?!

 

[MillionDollarDream]

Anyone else think MP kept Guidetti on the bench even with the game in hand because it would have been a bit overkill to bring on a ST? I think the subs made today were to keep starters fresh and sure up the win with defensive subs.

 

[cibaman]

He needs to be judged over the course of the season. Hopefully these early results away from home are just teething problems.

Clearly the longer you leave it to judge a manager the more accurate that judgement will be.

But I think it would be reasonable to form at least an interim judgement after the Arsenal game. That game and the ones at WBA and Southampton will have a significant impact on how the season will turn out. He will have had 24 competitive games to bed in his tactics. The injury situation should have eased.