Everton Thread - 2023/24

Status
Not open for further replies.
shackattack said:
Paragraph 84 - reference made to 5 years earlier that the EFL adopted sanctioning guidelines for breaches of it's PSR
Paragraph 85 - the PL has not incorporated any such guidelines in it's rules
Paragraph 86 - in August 23 - the PL board adopts a PSR sanctions policy which the Chief Executive presents to the Commision.
So they clearly changed the process and sanctions in order to present a case against Everton.
Paragraph 89 - registers the Commisions concern that it was set up on this basis by the PL and that there was an attempt to change it in the middle of the case

I would say there is evidence of an inappropriate attempt to influence due process.
I would also question how independent the Commission actually is. We end up with an arbitrary decision which appears to result from pressure applied by the PL.
Anyone can download the Commission report it's easy enough to do.
Click to expand...

We can't download it if we don't know where it is. Save us searching, and provide a link.
 
shackattack said:
So they clearly changed the process and sanctions in order to present a case against Everton.
Click to expand...

No, this is wrong.

The PL rules say, and have said for a long time, that the sanctions can be whatever is deemed appropriate by the independent panel.

Everton and other clubs fairly wanted to know what the sanctions might be considered appropriate so they asked the PL to block out roughly what they considered an appropriate sanction to be.

The Premier League did that, but reminded them all that the panel is independent and it’s them who decides ultimately.


There was no changing of rules, there was nothing done to spite Everton, there was no abuse of process (certainly no evidence of it)

Para 89 has absolutely no bearing in the document to your summary, I really think you’ve misunderstood that. Theres nothing to do with “an attempt to change the process”.
 
Paulmcfc2703 said:
Isn't the fact they voted for it the whole point though.

Back in 2013 they did it to maintain their position and tried to fuck over clubs trying to spend their owners money to improve.

We have told fans of other teams for years this was just to benefit the red tops but nobody cared. Now finally after all these years one of the turkeys want us to feel sorry for them at Christmas.
Click to expand...
Great analogy.
 
shackattack said:
Ifs and buts, if the teams you mentioned had performed better they'd have been further up the league. We messed up financially but does the punishment fit the crime so be it? Had we gone into administration we would have I believe only got a 9 points deduction.
So where did the PL get a 10 points deduction from. The lack of transparency in their process is alarming, and you get the impression they're making it up as they go along.
Click to expand...
Everton need to get on board with the blue clubs, City/Chelsea. Being Cucked by sticking with Red Tops. Go tell your blue mates.
 
Everton deserve a points deduction, They've been fiddling the books, They have also admitted that they have cheated and inflated figures.

The thing is, The rules that Everton have broken are the rules that they have agreed to along with every other Premier League Club, This is not an independent investigation, The Premier League is made up of it's members.

People also need to remember Everton were one of five teams to break away from the Football League and left the other 80 clubs to fend for themselves...

The media need to stop going on like that are being treated harshly, They are cheats and deserve the punishment that they are facing by the Premier League.

YouTube idiots along with Twitter idiots haven't a brain to bless themselves with, City's 115 charges are completely different to what Everton are being charged with by the Premier League.

Let's get it right, People aren't pissed off that Everton are being deducted points, They are pissed off that Manchester City aren't being punished and that's what all this boils down to really.
 
SWPISHOME said:
Everton deserve a points deduction, They've been fiddling the books, They have also admitted that they have cheated and inflated figures.

The thing is, The rules that Everton have broken are the rules that they have agreed to along with every other Premier League Club, This is not an independent investigation, The Premier League is made up of it's members.

People also need to remember Everton were one of five teams to break away from the Football League and left the other 80 clubs to fend for themselves...

The media need to stop going on like that are being treated harshly, They are cheats and deserve the punishment that they are facing by the Premier League.

YouTube idiots along with Twitter idiots haven't a brain to bless themselves with, City's 115 charges are completely different to what Everton are being charged with by the Premier League.

Let's get it right, People aren't pissed off that Everton are being deducted points, They are pissed off that Manchester City aren't being punished and that's what all this boils down to really.
Click to expand...

In a nutshell, this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.