HART
Made one rick that went unpunished as Naismith had strayed offside, but his dash out for the equaliser was reminiscent of his bad days last season 5
ZABALETA
Quite magnificent tackle on Lukaku and pass launched City's counter-attack that led to Fernandinho's goal, and he had a fine game all round 8
DEMICHELIS
Composure personified in the face of some sporadically intense Everton attacking, and he had to be as Mangala fell apart 7
MANGALA
Given a horrendous time by Lukaku, regularly beaten by a stronger, faster opponent – amazing he stayed on with Kompany on the bench 4
CLICHY
Faced the attacking threat of Coleman well, but was not his usual attacking self with City crying out for width on left 6
FERNANDO
Some smart interventions, but ruined that a little by giving the ball away too cheaply at first – but his passing gradually improved 6
FERNANDINHO
Right place at he right time for the goal, and he deserved it for a bright, enterprising midfield display – he is not Yaya, but only one man is! 7
NAVAS
Usual story of his pace unsettling the opposition, but too often the cross, or the shot, didn't find its target. Always involved. 6
SILVA
Quite brilliant at times, even with Barry sticking close, but some of those around him were not able to capitalise on the chancs he made 8
NASRI
Always looking to create and deliver, but this was one of those games where his best work never seemed to amount to anything 6
JOVETIC
Plenty of lively link play around the box, but he fell down when it came to shooting, or the final ball to a colleague and the substitution was inevitable 6
Muen ratings.............