FIFA Women's WC France 2019

[Dubai Blue]

If they're behind the line, its the same result, the new rule says one foot on it, they might as well just give a goal really.

This is insane, genuinely insane. Keepers have to generate momentum in order to stand any chance of making a save, so the sensible compromise would have been for them to just start a foot behind the line. That way they'd gain no advantage.

As you say, they may as well just award a penalty goal under this new rule as the keepers don't stand a chance.

 

[born2bblu]

VAR the way it is being employed at this moment in time is ruining football.

VAR is quickly going to kill the speed and fluidity of the game.

VAR will ruin the game. Said it all along. There's nowt wrong with the existing way - no VAR - talking points over a pint after the game. Instead it will be as bad if not worse than what we are seeing ................everyone who thinks the dippers and rags will no longer get the benefit of decisions but we will - think again. All clubs will need about 6 keepers as at least two will be suspended following a red card at any one time. Ref's won't make decisions - it will all end up with the square in the air but hey ho we will be getting the "right decisions" at last eh?

 

[Eds]

That’s the issue for me, it’s not conclusive.
The frame before she’s fine the frame after she’s not. Fine margi s like that should be left alone

Spot on

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Don’t understand why they’ve decided all of a sudden that penalties can be retaken after VAR spots that ‘keepers are off their line when it’s taken but Lloris being a yard off his line when he saved Sergio’s pen was absolutely fine

At that time I think it was only the 'handball' law change that was being brought forward following the fiasco they conjured up with the Otamendi 'handcornerball', which, in the second leg, the VAR wallahs and the ref failed to implement.

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Don’t understand why they’ve decided all of a sudden that penalties can be retaken after VAR spots that ‘keepers are off their line when it’s taken but Lloris being a yard off his line when he saved Sergio’s pen was absolutely fine

I think this retaking of pens is FICKFUFA's attempt to give VAR some legitimacy. VAR should deliver a result that reflects what happened on the pitch and teams win or lose according to that string of events. However, we have seen since its implementation a whole raft of VAR decisions that are clearly wrong. FICKFUFA seem to be of the opinion that a decision that VAR has delivered becomes the crown jewels of decisions. They seem to rule out that the VAR shed is populated by the same kind of whistling wanker that occasionally made complete howlers pre-VAR. The governing bodies will head down the path that delivers a game that is the sporting equivalent of homemade lottery ticket.

 

[Hoghead]

That’s the issue for me, it’s not conclusive.
The frame before she’s fine the frame after she’s not. Fine margi s like that should be left alone

But we have come to accept the fine margins with offside and how VAR interprets the rule.

 

[Cobra]

This is insane, genuinely insane. Keepers have to generate momentum in order to stand any chance of making a save, so the sensible compromise would have been for them to just start a foot behind the line. That way they'd gain no advantage.

As you say, they may as well just award a penalty goal under this new rule as the keepers don't stand a chance.

Well the Argentina keeper managed to save a penalty last night after keeping a foot on the line.

 

[squirtyflower]

But we have come to accept the fine margins with offside and how VAR interprets the rule.

No we shouldn’t have to accept anything.
If it’s such a fine margin it should be left alone

 

[cleavers]

But we have come to accept the fine margins with offside and how VAR interprets the rule.

You're missing a point though, the camera's making these decisions aren't precise enough in frames per second, so there is still doubt about these very small margins, and they are not better than the human eye.

 

[kev20971]

Sweden v USA and it's already 1 nil to America after 3mins