Goo said:alky313 said:Can you lads take your bickering elsewhere?
Been meaning to start a thread on this for ages...
In your opinion.Goo said:kp789 said:I never said that it was.Goo said:Extreme or not, just because you think something, or hold a certain opinion, doesn't make it automatically correct.
You claimed an opinion can't be incorrect. Which in itself is incorrect. That's all
GX Blue said:Goo said:alky313 said:Can you lads take your bickering elsewhere?
Been meaning to start a thread on this for ages...
I maybe to blame for this. Sorry!
I have zero interest in discussing the meaning of facts and opinions.
All im saying is kp789's opinion on Bale and Reus was just awful.
He can either waffle on about it or take it on the chin and ignore me or even better explain why he wants Reus more than Bale.
Quick thanks to Goo for taking up the argument about opinions and facts. Couldn’t think of a more boring discussion this morning :-)
kp789 said:In your opinion.Goo said:kp789 said:I never said that it was.
You claimed an opinion can't be incorrect. Which in itself is incorrect. That's all
Take what on the chin?GX Blue said:Goo said:alky313 said:Can you lads take your bickering elsewhere?
Been meaning to start a thread on this for ages...
I maybe to blame for this. Sorry!
I have zero interest in discussing the meaning of facts and opinions.
All im saying is kp789's opinion on Bale and Reus was just awful.
He can either waffle on about it or take it on the chin and ignore me or even better explain why he wants Reus more than Bale.
Quick thanks to Goo for taking up the argument about opinions and facts. Couldn’t think of a more boring discussion this morning :-)
kp789 said:Take what on the chin?GX Blue said:Goo said:Been meaning to start a thread on this for ages...
I maybe to blame for this. Sorry!
I have zero interest in discussing the meaning of facts and opinions.
All im saying is kp789's opinion on Bale and Reus was just awful.
He can either waffle on about it or take it on the chin and ignore me or even better explain why he wants Reus more than Bale.
Quick thanks to Goo for taking up the argument about opinions and facts. Couldn’t think of a more boring discussion this morning :-)
Why Reus? He is more of a team player, Bale likes to do it himself. Reus would cost less and if you look at his statistics they are very similar to Bale in terms of goals, assists etc.
I don't like Bale's attitude, yes he is a good player, but the whole diving thing irritates me. He is also only really effective on the wing. Reus can play as a second striker or on either wing.
It just makes more sense to go for Reus.
I am intrigued.Goo said:GX Blue said:Goo said:Been meaning to start a thread on this for ages...
I maybe to blame for this. Sorry!
I have zero interest in discussing the meaning of facts and opinions.
All im saying is kp789's opinion on Bale and Reus was just awful.
He can either waffle on about it or take it on the chin and ignore me or even better explain why he wants Reus more than Bale.
Quick thanks to Goo for taking up the argument about opinions and facts. Couldn’t think of a more boring discussion this morning :-)
It's actually a very interesting argument, especially when in the context of political and social debates, but whatever.
I harbor no ill feelings towards either of you for any of your opinions, you can think what you want. But just because you think something, or have an opinion, doesn't make it right, and isn't immune from being completely wrong.
So anyway, Reus or Bale?
-- Fri Apr 26, 2013 10:45 am --
kp789 said:In your opinion.Goo said:You claimed an opinion can't be incorrect. Which in itself is incorrect. That's all
Nope that's a fact... Which is different to an opinion... See my post above, I've already proved the difference.
If you want more case studies, I'm more than happy to PM you some.
I will assume you have seen more of Bale than Reus? Which I have too. Both are undoutably gifted players. Do you not rate Reus or do you just prefer Bale?GX Blue said:kp789 said:Take what on the chin?GX Blue said:I maybe to blame for this. Sorry!
I have zero interest in discussing the meaning of facts and opinions.
All im saying is kp789's opinion on Bale and Reus was just awful.
He can either waffle on about it or take it on the chin and ignore me or even better explain why he wants Reus more than Bale.
Quick thanks to Goo for taking up the argument about opinions and facts. Couldn’t think of a more boring discussion this morning :-)
Why Reus? He is more of a team player, Bale likes to do it himself. Reus would cost less and if you look at his statistics they are very similar to Bale in terms of goals, assists etc.
I don't like Bale's attitude, yes he is a good player, but the whole diving thing irritates me. He is also only really effective on the wing. Reus can play as a second striker or on either wing.
It just makes more sense to go for Reus.
Fair enough buddy.
Not for me though.
kp789 said:I am intrigued.Goo said:GX Blue said:I maybe to blame for this. Sorry!
I have zero interest in discussing the meaning of facts and opinions.
All im saying is kp789's opinion on Bale and Reus was just awful.
He can either waffle on about it or take it on the chin and ignore me or even better explain why he wants Reus more than Bale.
Quick thanks to Goo for taking up the argument about opinions and facts. Couldn’t think of a more boring discussion this morning :-)
It's actually a very interesting argument, especially when in the context of political and social debates, but whatever.
I harbor no ill feelings towards either of you for any of your opinions, you can think what you want. But just because you think something, or have an opinion, doesn't make it right, and isn't immune from being completely wrong.
So anyway, Reus or Bale?
-- Fri Apr 26, 2013 10:45 am --
kp789 said:In your opinion.
Nope that's a fact... Which is different to an opinion... See my post above, I've already proved the difference.
If you want more case studies, I'm more than happy to PM you some.
I have always believed that to have an opinion, is to hold some sort of view or belief on a subject whether it be right or wrong, correct or incorrect. So for example, I could believe that people were always following me, when in reality no one is. But my belief would be that I am being followed despite the contrary being fact. I struggle to see where the line can be drawn if you see where I am coming from. I am not taking issue with you, I just disagree with your argument but please try and convince me as like you say, it is a very interesting and vast topic.
-- Fri Apr 26, 2013 10:53 am --
I will assume you have seen more of Bale than Reus? Which I have too. Both are undoutably gifted players. Do you not rate Reus or do you just prefer Bale?GX Blue said:kp789 said:Take what on the chin?
Why Reus? He is more of a team player, Bale likes to do it himself. Reus would cost less and if you look at his statistics they are very similar to Bale in terms of goals, assists etc.
I don't like Bale's attitude, yes he is a good player, but the whole diving thing irritates me. He is also only really effective on the wing. Reus can play as a second striker or on either wing.
It just makes more sense to go for Reus.
Fair enough buddy.
Not for me though.
kp789 said:I would take Reus over Bale.
Matt.D said:SuperYaya said:TCIB said:I wouldn't be happy if we got him for any more than 35mil.
I'd probably be excited because I always am when we sign someone, but I think you're right that is a waste of money.
Bale is overrated and doesn't really fit our system. Not to say he's not a good player though.
Some of the shit I read on here is unbelievable.
Chevelle said:ANY1ablue, thanks for your info mate.. hope it goes through please keep up the info :) we all appreciate it
spinzer said:Then id put Gundogan instead of Barry.alky313 said:The Man With The Stick said:If we're gettin a bit 'Football Manager' about it... I'd have both of them instead of Cavani, Falcao etc. Those two either side of Aguero would be somethin to behold!
Just can't see it though... too much money
I agree... Stick Silva in the hole behind Aguero... Holy fucki.
------------Aguero-----------
Bale--------Silva---------Reus
----------Barry----Yaya-------
------------Aguero-----------
Bale--------Silva---------Reus
----------Gundogan----Yaya-------
100 goals done.. :D
Holy Cream this offensive line.
Why?ANY1aBLUE said:kp789 said:I would take Reus over Bale.
One word - tosh.............
cordonbleu said:To continue with my previous post,
Bale's team play is very poor for the amount of time he has on the ball and chances he has to make a pass or shot on goal. To reiterate AVB has built up a style of play that works around Bale and I suspect that this is the reason for his shining this season. He is placed in a position of the likes of the Messi or Ronaldo of his team and has done a very good job at creating a book of tactical moves which 9 times out of 10 result in Bale receiving the ball.
Perhaps, Spurs have been trying hard to sell him in near future, if not this summer, then next summer.
johnmc said:Not sure how anyone would argue Bale isnt ideal for our team.
Would add much needed pace, will take a shot from outside the box which is a rarity at the minute, versatile and would actually scare teams.
Id break the bank personally.
As a player, I don't dispute that he would be a great addition to any team. However, I think realistically he would not choose city. Add to this the fact of many financial implications.johnmc said:Not sure how anyone would argue Bale isnt ideal for our team.
Would add much needed pace, will take a shot from outside the box which is a rarity at the minute, versatile and would actually scare teams.
Id break the bank personally.
kp789 said:How can a opinion be "worst"? Surely the whole pretence of having an opinion is that it is, an 'opinion', an individuals view, it can't be right or wrong.GX Blue said:kp789 said:I would take Reus over Bale.
Thats the worst opinion ive heard for a while.
In your opinionVincents Tackle said:kp789 said:How can a opinion be "worst"? Surely the whole pretence of having an opinion is that it is, an 'opinion', an individuals view, it can't be right or wrong.GX Blue said:Thats the worst opinion ive heard for a while.
That's a matter of opinion
kp789 said:As a player, I don't dispute that he would be a great addition to any team. However, I think realistically he would not choose city. Add to this the fact of many financial implications.