The Villa performance was not good but I think overall we were far far worse in the first half of last season. And consistently so.
I remember playing Southampton in the League Cup thinking that apart from the odd exception we hadn’t played well in months and we were at nearly full strength then. We’d lost to Brentford and Liverpool, been held by Everton, scraped by Fulham and Chelsea - then we lost to United… We were totally out of sorts and didn’t seem to dominate the ball at all. It wasn’t until the Forest game in mid-Feb (which we didn’t even win) that I thought we may have finally turned a corner.
Our underperformance this year is much easier to diagnose. Key injuries, Rodri suspension, sloppy defending late in games. If we’d managed the game a fraction better in the last 10 mins in 2 of the 4 games where we dropped points, this thread simply wouldn’t exist.
That doesn’t mean we’re going to sweep it all, but it doesn’t feel anything like as dire as last year to me. A year in which we won the treble. So I will reserve judgment for at least another 3-4 months…