I guess it depends what you want out of the matchday experience
People banging on about atmosphere and being able to have a pie and a pint and still get change out of a fiver, yea great a decent atmosphere is what everyone wants
But me im a football purist, i go to City cause I love City and I don't have 'second teams'. It doesn't bother me what the atmosphere is like, who is in the squad or how much a hot dog costs, I go to City cause their my team and the way it stands at the moment its great watching these players play week in week our regardless of how much they earn
Personally i couldn't think of anything worse than going watching a bunch of bang average semi professional footballers just so I can stand and have a watered down pint of piss and a steak pie and be surrounded by people singing and jumping up and down for 90 minutes pretending their part of something diverse