If we win FA cup would you keep Mancini?

[Phil1]

Getting away from the petty backbiting that seems to have infiltrated this thread.

IMO, Mancini should stay regardless of an FA Cup win or otherwise - we wouldn't get better and even if it were possible then whoever came in would be stuck with RM's squad because we can't splash out to rebuild at this juncture.
The upset would be a disaster so lets have some continuity and allow Roberto to bring his younger players on and develop his log term plan.

IMO (and I stress the IMO part) he's a truly great manager and much loved by the thousands who sing his name at every game.

Well he didn't put the likes of Saurez, Pozo, Razak etc on the bench yesterday and secondly all he keeps going on about his spending more money on the likes of De Rossi and RVP so are younger players in his plan?

-- Mon Feb 18, 2013 7:20 pm --

I will let you start the thread nipholmes
You seem to think the forum will agree with you
Mancini v wenger....

The average football fan would say Wenger imo

Ah well, if nothing else I'm glad I'm not an average football fan.. :-)

 

[greasedupdeafguy]

Getting away from the petty backbiting that seems to have infiltrated this thread.

IMO, Mancini should stay regardless of an FA Cup win or otherwise - we wouldn't get better and even if it were possible then whoever came in would be stuck with RM's squad because we can't splash out to rebuild at this juncture.
The upset would be a disaster so lets have some continuity and allow Roberto to bring his younger players on and develop his log term plan.

IMO (and I stress the IMO part) he's a truly great manager and much loved by the thousands who sing his name at every game.

Well he didn't put the likes of Saurez, Pozo, Razak etc on the bench yesterday and secondly all he keeps going on about his spending more money on the likes of De Rossi and RVP so are younger players in his plan?

-- Mon Feb 18, 2013 7:20 pm --

I will let you start the thread nipholmes
You seem to think the forum will agree with you
Mancini v wenger....

The average football fan would say Wenger imo

Age is against Wenger on this one, especially if he was to start at a new club.

Is anyone saying sack Mancini and bring in Wenger?
Wenger is the better manager I think the average football fan would agree, would I have him over Mancini yes but he isn't going to come here so its a pointless debate.

 

[Bluebee2]

Well he didn't put the likes of Saurez, Pozo, Razak etc on the bench yesterday and secondly all he keeps going on about his spending more money on the likes of De Rossi and RVP so are younger players in his plan?

-- Mon Feb 18, 2013 7:20 pm --


The average football fan would say Wenger imo

Age is against Wenger on this one, especially if he was to start at a new club.

Is anyone saying sack Mancini and bring in Wenger?
Wenger is the better manager I think the average football fan would agree, would I have him over Mancini yes but he isn't going to come here so its a pointless debate.

I really don't see how you arrive at that conclusion, and believe me I'm not a big fan of Mancini, but if Wenger is that good a Manager why has he not won a trophy in nearly 8 years ?

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.sincearsenallastwonatrophy.co.uk/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.sincearsenallastwonatrophy.co.uk/</a>

 

[NipHolmes]

O'k deal
Lets see how many would swap wenger for mancini
Thats what the argument is..

Ask who is the best manager, that's what you asked me!

Go on a neutral forum too. It's best way to get proper answer. Also ask who is better Jose or Mancini and also ask who is better Savic or Boateng.

I'll give you the number for Samaritans when you've done. You'll fry your head when you don't get the responses you want.

Also, without trying to be funny, there's a stark contrast in 'intelligent debate/posts' between for and against. Take that how you will and twist it how you want, couldn't care. The reasoning is there for all to see.

Go on a neutral forum please. This is the same forum that didn't want RVP ffs.

You fucking shithouse
You have just said ask the forum who is better
Do you want to ask bluemoon who they would rather have in charge yes or no?

No. I'm asking for a level playing field. Most here wouldnt have RvP or Ronaldo.

Ask say Rawk or even a football forum for all clubs.

Not much to ask is it? Unless you like the Robert Mugabe style of Democracy?

I'm a cleverer shithouse than you. That's what's getting to you.

 

[bernabias home shirt]

Well he didn't put the likes of Saurez, Pozo, Razak etc on the bench yesterday and secondly all he keeps going on about his spending more money on the likes of De Rossi and RVP so are younger players in his plan?

-- Mon Feb 18, 2013 7:20 pm --


The average football fan would say Wenger imo

Age is against Wenger on this one, especially if he was to start at a new club.

Is anyone saying sack Mancini and bring in Wenger?
Wenger is the better manager I think the average football fan would agree, would I have him over Mancini yes but he isn't going to come here so its a pointless debate.

Do you not think its weird that the 5 or 6 who would rather have wenger are the same 5 or 6 who are constantly posting for bobby to go?

 

[malg]

This thread, and half the fucking idiotic opinions in it must have links to it on RAWK and Rag Cafe. What a shambles. Hopefully the tiff between the two posters will get heated and a MOD will pull it.

 

[NipHolmes]

Well he didn't put the likes of Saurez, Pozo, Razak etc on the bench yesterday and secondly all he keeps going on about his spending more money on the likes of De Rossi and RVP so are younger players in his plan?

-- Mon Feb 18, 2013 7:20 pm --


The average football fan would say Wenger imo

Age is against Wenger on this one, especially if he was to start at a new club.

Is anyone saying sack Mancini and bring in Wenger?
Wenger is the better manager I think the average football fan would agree, would I have him over Mancini yes but he isn't going to come here so its a pointless debate.

The question started who's better, I said Wenger. That's now been tested although I've sated a few times I rate Jose and Klopp higher.

Cookie seems unwilling to tell the truth andrhas restored to telling lies and twisting things. His level of debate is about half inch in measurement.

I've asked for Jose or Wenger, still no response from him, nor one on my Moratti posts.

Texas through this thread. Everyone can see what hs upto.

 

[I'm no cynic but...]

This thread, and half the fucking idiotic opinions in it must have links to it on RAWK and Rag Cafe. What a shambles. Hopefully the tiff between the two posters will get heated and a MOD will pull it.

Please God, let it be so!

 

[greasedupdeafguy]

Age is against Wenger on this one, especially if he was to start at a new club.

Is anyone saying sack Mancini and bring in Wenger?
Wenger is the better manager I think the average football fan would agree, would I have him over Mancini yes but he isn't going to come here so its a pointless debate.

I really don't see how you arrive at that conclusion, and believe me I'm not a big fan of Mancini, but if Wenger is that good a Manager why has he not won a trophy in nearly 8 years ?

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.sincearsenallastwonatrophy.co.uk/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.sincearsenallastwonatrophy.co.uk/</a>

If you've read through the thread Nipholmes has given valid reasons why, you cant expect him to win the league when his best players are sold every season. He has got them then to a CL final, qualified from the CL group stages every year, gets top 4 every season and constantly develops sides who play good, attractive football.

 

[NipHolmes]

Age is against Wenger on this one, especially if he was to start at a new club.

Is anyone saying sack Mancini and bring in Wenger?
Wenger is the better manager I think the average football fan would agree, would I have him over Mancini yes but he isn't going to come here so its a pointless debate.

Do you not think its weird that the 5 or 6 who would rather have wenger are the same 5 or 6 who are constantly posting for bobby to go?

Improvement.

Simple as that.

He's a better manager at just about every aspect.

Make a thread on a neutral forum. If you have faith in your opinion you'll do it

Mugabe.