Is Tevez better than Rooney?

[Grand Master Ram Rod]

Rooney's the second best player in the world and the first is an Argie. Unfortunately it's not Tevez though, he has some way to go to overtake Rooney.

 

[Superbia]

YES

All i see from Rooney is tap-ins and headers.

Please tell me what you see in Rooney over Tevez.

If we are going off the quality of goals Garrido must be right up there then ;-)

 

[stonerblue]

On the present form of both i'd go for Carlos.

Tevez has gone thoruh a lot off the pitch in the last couple of months but still manages to keep his head in the game. His goal against Chelski was as good as any i've seen the granny shagger score this season.

 

[borassic]

I don't think Carlos gets the credit he deserves.

 

[GStar]

Rooney's the second best player in the world and the first is an Argie. Unfortunately it's not Tevez though, he has some way to go to overtake Rooney.

No he isn't, he'd be at the bottom end of a top 10 imo. And before this season he was nowhere near it, the rest have been in and around there for years.

His close control is simply fantastic, his work ethic is great but his consistency infront of goal isn't.

Messi
Ronaldo
Torres
Drogba
Iniesta
Xavi
Higuain
then maybe Rooney, although Eto'o, Ibrahimovic, Casilias et al might all want a say about that.

 

[robbieh]

Rooney's the second best player in the world and the first is an Argie. Unfortunately it's not Tevez though, he has some way to go to overtake Rooney.

Can't go with that.

I'd have quite a few of the Barca players in front of him, not to mention Ronaldo. And have you seen Higuain in front of goal.

And for me Tevez is the equal of Rooney at the moment.

 

[Grand Master Ram Rod]

Rooney's the second best player in the world and the first is an Argie. Unfortunately it's not Tevez though, he has some way to go to overtake Rooney.

No he isn't, he'd be at the bottom end of a top 10 imo. And before this season he was nowhere near it, the rest have been in and around there for years.

His close control is simply fantastic, his work ethic is great but his consistency infront of goal isn't.

Messi
Ronaldo
Torres
Drogba
Iniesta
Xavi
Higuain
then maybe Rooney, although Eto'o, Ibrahimovic, Casilias et al might all want a say about that.

Rooney is better than all them but Messi.

This is just like when people were calling Tevez crap cos he didn't score many and now people are saying he's nearly best in the world. Tevez has always been class and always scored goals, just like Rooney. Just because they're doing better than ever this season, doesn't mean they've been incosistent players.

Rooney's all round game is better than probably everyone on that list (including Messi), but people are only just starting to take notice because he's bagging nearly every game. He'd be better than Messi too if Messi wasn't unhuman. Take the blue tinted glasses off boys.

 

[borassic]

No he isn't, he'd be at the bottom end of a top 10 imo. And before this season he was nowhere near it, the rest have been in and around there for years.
His close control is simply fantastic, his work ethic is great but his consistency infront of goal isn't.
Messi
Ronaldo
Torres
Drogba
Iniesta
Xavi
Higuain
then maybe Rooney, although Eto'o, Ibrahimovic, Casilias et al might all want a say about that.

Don't think you can say that Higuain is more consistant at all. He's a cracking player but I don't think he's at rooneys level. Iniesta has also been out of form. Rooney is for me the 3rd best player in the world.

 

[bridgeblue]

As red nose said Tevez is NOT a 20 goal a season man,he`s a 30 goal a season man. Rooney is the second best player in the world, with Tevez 3rd.

 

[Tricky_Trev]

Tevez is not as good as Rooney, but i'd say that he's the closest thing to Rooney in world football.