It's Quiet 18 - Wanna ring the bell?

[simon23]

Tell us why you don't see a 100m playerThink it depends on wht we are looking

think it depends on what we are looking for

Rice as a replacement for Phillips is an upgrade.....

Rice to replace anyone else (Gundo for instance) is a downgrade - Rice is good at spraying the ball around from the back when he has time...but does he have the ability with the ball at his feet in tight spaces and under a intense press - im not so sure he does.....Where as i would say FDJ does have that...Rice may have the upper hand in being more physical however which would help defensively.

Im not saying this is right but when people see a 100m price tag maybe they want a complete player.....or someone of really high techincal ability - like a Bernardo type player (I know they are rare) - I dont see that personally with Rice....

 

[Mad 4 It]

I could see Rice Bellingham FDJ coming in and Phillips Bernie and Gundo leaving. Would that we a step down or up or about the same. Cancelo and Laporte going and Gvardiol coming in. That’s four in who might be 5th. The left back from Munich would be nice :)

 

[richards30]

I could see Rice Bellingham FDJ coming in and Phillips Bernie and Gundo leaving. Would that we a step down or up or about the same. Cancelo and Laporte going and Gvardiol coming in. That’s four in who might be 5th. The left back from Munich would be nice :)

No way we get all of the first 3 mate, as nice as that would be though! Not enough game time for everyone and no need for all 3 imo.

 

[FantasyIreland]

think it depends on what we are looking for

Rice as a replacement for Phillips is an upgrade.....

Rice to replace anyone else (Gundo for instance) is a downgrade - Rice is good at spraying the ball around from the back when he has time...but does he have the ability with the ball at his feet in tight spaces and under a intense press - im not so sure he does.....Where as i would say FDJ does have that...Rice may have the upper hand in being more physical however which would help defensively.

Im not saying this is right but when people see a 100m price tag maybe they want a complete player.....or someone of really high techincal ability - like a Bernardo type player (I know they are rare) - I dont see that personally with Rice....

I do see it.

Like you,i was previously convinced his ability was limited to the above.....a decent defensive midfielder with limited technical ability.Having watched him much more closely over the past few games,i have changed my opinion completely.

He has superb all round ability,probably,due to his athleticism,more of a complete midfield general than Rodri (not specialist Defensive though) and more adaptable when it comes to squad versatility.I genuinely think they could play in the same pivot or trio,and few,if any,midfielders would be stronger.

100m is mental money,but looking at rumoured prices for players like Toney......we are now in that territory.

I think this line up would be superb

Walker----Stones--Dias----Ake
------------Rice--Rodri-------------
-----Foden-----Kev---Grealish---
--------------Haaland-------

 

[christened at st marks]

Really? You fancy Rice over FDJ? ..not sarcasm, genuine question. Seems a few others are of a similar persuasion, so I’m wondering if I’m missing something, but I just don’t see a £100m player.

DeJong is great and would love him at City, I never see Rice do anything wrong always stands out and I just think he suits our needs better, he can rotate with Rodri or Stones and play the Gundo role as a deep lying play maker which FDJ can do but not to rotate with Rodri or Stones.
If Rodri was injured for the cup final against the scum I'd sooner have Rice than FDJ as a DM
If Gundo was injured then FDJ over Rice but we have replacements for Gundo.
Thats why I feel he suits our needs better and I'm sure others Bellingham McAlister or whoever will be recruited as well to replace Gundo or hoping not Bernie.

 

[christened at st marks]

I know he’s gonna leave, but it’s still absolutely gutting to see that, especially when we still have all these important games left this season.

Thats why the scum of a club have no respect, all they care about is PR

 

[FantasyIreland]

DeJong is great and would love him at City, I never see Rice do anything wrong always stands out and I just think he suits our needs better, he can rotate with Rodri or Stones and play the Gundo role as a deep lying play maker which FDJ can do but not to rotate with Rodri or Stones.
If Rodri was injured for the cup final against the scum I'd sooner have Rice than FDJ as a DM
If Gundo was injured then FDJ over Rice but we have replacements for Gundo.
Thats why I feel he suits our needs better and I'm sure others Bellingham McAlister or whoever will be recruited as well to replace Gundo or hoping not Bernie.

Yep,total agreement.

Rice and MacAllister would be incredible business,they would make the loss of Gundo and the need to replace Philips seemless and would completely covers our bases.

It would also save the potential of what is increasingly looking,admittedly media driven,like a circus where Bellingham is concerned.

 

[blueparrot]

I do see it.

Like you,i was previously convinced his ability was limited to the above.....a decent defensive midfielder with limited technical ability.Having watched him much more closely over the past few games,i have changed my opinion completely.

He has superb all round ability,probably,due to his athleticism,more of a complete midfield general than Rodri (not specialist Defensive though) and more adaptable when it comes to squad versatility.I genuinely think they could play in the same pivot or trio,and few,if any,midfielders would be stronger.

100m is mental money,but looking at rumoured prices for players like Toney......we are now in that territory.

I think this line up would be superb

Walker----Stones--Dias----Ake
------------Rice--Rodri-------------
-----Foden-----Kev---Grealish---
--------------Haaland-------

My problem with that is I see it as too defensive and Stones and Rice doing a defensive job Stones can do himself. I am however open to being convinced Rice can play a more attacking role to replace Gudogan. I 've never seen him play that role but others ssem to think he can, if Peps one that can then then I'm in.
Though with that line up it would be Rice instead of Bellingham,who to my mind is a more suitable Gundogan replacement, so question is,is Rice the best Bellingham alternative?

 

[FantasyIreland]

My problem with that is I see it as too defensive and Stones and Rodri doing a defensive job Stones can do himself. I am however open to being convinced Rice can play a more attacking role to replace Gudogan. I 've never seen him play that role but others ssem to think he can, if Peps one that can then then I'm in.
Though with that line up it would be Rice instead of Bellingham,who to my mind is a more suitable Gundogan replacement, so question is,is Rice the best Bellingham alternative?

@BlueHammer85

What you think? can Rice play a more advanced role? while also having the ability to get stuck in.

I think so,plus how ca a team with KDB,Grealish,Foden and Haaland be deemed too defensive?

Sign MacAllister too,and our options are there if we want the more attacking side.

 

[BlueHammer85]

@BlueHammer85

What you think? can Rice play a more advanced role? while also having the ability to get stuck in.

I think so,plus how ca a team with KDB,Grealish,Foden and Haaland be deemed too defensive?

Sign MacAllister too,and our options are there if we want the more attacking side.

What the hells this thread ?!

As for Rice, He’s certainly an all round midfielder, but not sure id posistion him in an advanced attacking mid role - his defensive side of the game is just too good.

He doesn’t possess the attacking and shooting instincts the likes of Grealish, Foden etc have for you.

So has to be in Rodri role, he can carry the ball from box to box and has long range passing ability that often doesn’t get mentioned. He’s a world class player and any of you big boy clubs will be lucky to have him.