It's Quiet 32 - enter at own risk

Think were done both in and out. Sadly, I suspect we will pay heavily for going into a season with just 3 cbs. Every other big side has 4 minimum. We’re going into the new season weaker than we ended the last in a position that was widely regarded as our weakest area.

It's going to be something that we might suffer from in the big games. Remains to be seen. I don't think we can get away with playing Fernandinho as centre half against a Liverpool or a Spurs, and it may well come to that.
 
will be crazy to go without buying another CB! if something happens to laporte and stones has a form wobble we are in big trouble!
 
Otamendi, Danilo, Garcia and Fernandinho are more than capable. Harwood- Bellis is an exciting prospect, too.


Otamendi is washed up. Danilo, Fernandinho are mere makeshift centre halves who will fill in for a game or 2 max, not a direct solution if injury/bad form for Stones or Laporte. Garcia and Harwood-Bellis not first team ready yet.

The need for a centre half has never been more evident.
 
I still think, or hope, that we will sign Cancelo in place of Danilo and a CB instead of Otamendi.
Losing a player and a leader like Kompany and not bring any replacements would be a huge mistake for us, especially with Otamendi that wasn't good enough last year and Stones who has a tendency to make a lot of mistakes
 
Otamendi is washed up. Danilo, Fernandinho are mere makeshift centre halves who will fill in for a game or 2 max, not a direct solution if injury/bad form for Stones or Laporte. Garcia and Harwood-Bellis not first team ready yet.

The need for a centre half has never been more evident.

Otamendi is far from washed up. I would like to see Garcia get a run at some point, I think he will play all the League Cup games as a minimum.

Squad rules dictate you can't have everything you want. You need to suck it up and have some faith in the youth players.
 
I still think, or hope, that we will sign Cancelo in place of Danilo and a CB instead of Otamendi.
Losing a player and a leader like Kompany and not bring any replacements would be a huge mistake for us, especially with Otamendi that wasn't good enough last year and Stones who has a tendency to make a lot of mistakes

ruben dias and cancelo would boost us short and long term
 
Otamendi is washed up. Danilo, Fernandinho are mere makeshift centre halves who will fill in for a game or 2 max, not a direct solution if injury/bad form for Stones or Laporte. Garcia and Harwood-Bellis not first team ready yet.

The need for a centre half has never been more evident.
Nico is not at all washed up,he is down the pecking order because vinny got fit,he is the best back up defender we could have
 
I don't see it that way.

We can not buy a foreign player without dropping one of the list. No player deserves to be dropped and buying before selling puts you in a bad place so its a non starter.
Buying an association trained player that improves the squad without paying stupid money is not possible.

There is no struggle here. We are a well run club that makes very calculated moves.

Honestly speaking what English player would benefit us and fit into our squad at a reasonable price. Go for Kane its going to be 200 million in this market Spurs will want.
Maguire looking for 80 odd million.
The rest wouldnt add anything better than what we have at the moment it seems.
No value in those players.
 
Think were done both in and out. Sadly, I suspect we will pay heavily for going into a season with just 3 cbs. Every other big side has 4 minimum. We’re going into the new season weaker than we ended the last in a position that was widely regarded as our weakest area.
People have said that about the left back and holding midfield positions for the last two years, both positions were filled very capably by players who people said could never do so. If Delph, Zinchenko and Gundogan can play in unfamiliar positions and we still as a team manage to get 100 and 98 points respectively, then I’m sure one of our most experienced and intelligent players in Fernandinho can cover centre back pretty comfortably. It wouldn’t surprise me if he became first choice alongside Laporte over the course of the season, he’s that good.
 
Otamendi is washed up. Danilo, Fernandinho are mere makeshift centre halves who will fill in for a game or 2 max, not a direct solution if injury/bad form for Stones or Laporte. Garcia and Harwood-Bellis not first team ready yet.

The need for a centre half has never been more evident.

You might well be right about the others but I still believe Otamendi is one of the better centre backs in the league.

But Stones’s propensity to make careless errors is admittedly a worry.

I’d be satisfied with someone like Ake from Bournemouth.
 
As we are likely to get a transfer ban I would have thought we would have brought a centre back in. It is looking like we could be done though.
 
Was just about to post that mate! Lol we are being naive if we don’t think they will ban us after the window shuts!
How do you know we’re not planning to integrate Garcia and Harwood-Bellis over the course of this coming season? If that is the plan which judging by the quality they both have is more than conceivable then it’s far from naive. Bringing in a player who would stunt their development is naive, in respect of failing to plan for the long term future.

I bet you’re one of the majority going mental at us allowing Sancho to leave but in a similar situation you don’t react accordingly.
 
How do you know we’re not planning to integrate Garcia and Harwood-Bellis over the course of this coming season? If that is the plan which judging by the quality they both have is more than conceivable then it’s far from naive. Bringing in a player who would stunt their development is naive, in respect of failing to plan for the long term future.

I bet you’re one of the majority going mental at us allowing Sancho to leave but in a similar situation you don’t react accordingly.

No? We didn’t allow sancho to leave though, he left, big difference
 
Why isn't pep signing players, It looks like he is going to leave us high and dry when we get a transfer ban and can't get any players, we will slip to mid-table again and Pep will join the rags and make them the superpower again :(
 
No? We didn’t allow sancho to leave though, he left, big difference
Why did he leave?
A lack of opportunities and minutes, exactly the same situation as Diaz.

If we buy another centre back now, one or both of Garcia and Harwood-Bellis will run their contracts down just the same as Diaz and Sancho.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top