It's Quiet thread 14 - 'do one' edition

[mosssideblue]

It's unclear to me why exactly he'd be worth significantly more than £20m? He's been off and on injured for two seasons now, when he does play he's seemingly good for one calamity a game, and more recently he's been benched by a 19 year old. Then you add on his wages, higher than the top earners at any club outside the top six, and the fact that he's been playing in a system that few other teams will play. Oh, and the market is depressed this summer.

I agree with you bud

 

[OliMCFC]

Otamendi is far less an issue.

Earns considerably less than Stones and out of contract next summer.

He can count on a lot more suitors abroad than Stones has in England.

I think we would be foolish to sell Stones this summer. Garcia is not as good at this time and might never be.

Might be foolish for us to sell Stones this summer but if he wants back in at England he needs to go.

 

[mosssideblue]

Might be foolish for us to sell Stones this summer but if he wants back in at England he needs to go.

I'd go the other way bud and say it would be foolish not to sell him if an opportunity arises.

 

[nmc]

Otamendi is far less an issue.

Earns considerably less than Stones and out of contract next summer.

He can count on a lot more suitors abroad than Stones has in England.

I think we would be foolish to sell Stones this summer. Garcia is not as good at this time and might never be.

Maybe extend Stones and loan him to Arsenal - a year getting regular football might rehabilitate him and get him in the England squad ahead of the Euro's.

 

[OB1]

Otamendi is far less an issue.

Earns considerably less than Stones and out of contract next summer.

He can count on a lot more suitors abroad than Stones has in England.

I think we would be foolish to sell Stones this summer. Garcia is not as good at this time and might never be.

I'd rather keep Stones than Garcia.

 

[OliMCFC]

I'd go the other way bud and say it would be foolish not to sell him if an opportunity arises.

I personally want him gone but think Tolmie had a point. But Stones needs to go, best for both parties imo

 

[ricky77]

Otamendi is far less an issue.

Earns considerably less than Stones and out of contract next summer.

He can count on a lot more suitors abroad than Stones has in England.

I think we would be foolish to sell Stones this summer. Garcia is not as good at this time and might never be.

Just checking , but is Otamendi not in contract until June 2022 ?

 

[willipp]

Maybe extend Stones and loan him to Arsenal - a year getting regular football might rehabilitate him and get him in the England squad ahead of the Euro's.

In all seriousness, why would Stones consider signing a new deal? He's gonna be 4th choice at best after this summer it seems if he does stay and if he has any hopes of being a starter in the euros then he would have to move. Arsenal would be a perfect move for him i think and they would probably be one of the few sides to pay him wages hed want.

 

[mccity]

All of a sudden I'm starting to feel like I'm part of a minority that rates Garcia.

 

[cjn]

In all seriousness, why would Stones consider signing a new deal? He's gonna be 4th choice at best after this summer it seems if he does stay and if he has any hopes of being a starter in the euros then he would have to move. Arsenal would be a perfect move for him i think and they would probably be one of the few sides to pay him wages hed want.

Because he can lock in £150k a week for another 5 years?