Jack Byrne

[BXLBlue]

Personally I think Byrne should take Delph's place in the squad (he can pass and shoot and he's got loads of attitude - I think Pep will like him). If we send him on loan again a promoted Girona would be great, but Spanish second tier not so much. I'd rather see him to go to NYCFC than spend a second season in Holland, unless it's with one of the teams playing in Europe as well. Any chance that Pep could help sort a loan to the Bundesliga? Hertha Berlin, Mainz, Leverkusen or Moenchengladbach all in Europe, but there are plenty of other decent teams where he could do well.

Could not agree more, he needs minutes in the pro world, going back to the youth set up now would ruin him.
He needs stretching much more than the Juliper league. We have Thomas Agyepong at Twente and that would be better however there is a much better option, which with a bit of luck could be his door into a much better league.....




Not a prayer either of them will take him. Not because it is him but they rightly have their own players and want to progress them. They also have players all over that league on loan. There is absolutely no incentive to for them to take him or even want to develop him.

The summer will be interesting for him as pep may want to keep him or the answer could be closer to home in that Girona are one point of the play offs and 7 points off a direct promotion with 5 matches left. Fingers crossed. If Girona get in La Liga, Pep can have a word with his brother and Byrne will be exposed to the best finishing school in the world, La Liga. He will learn far more there than in Eredivisie or the thud and blunder of the Championship or the SPL.

wo

 

[KenTheLandlord]

Personally I think Byrne should take Delph's place in the squad (he can pass and shoot and he's got loads of attitude - I think Pep will like him). If we send him on loan again a promoted Girona would be great, but Spanish second tier not so much. I'd rather see him to go to NYCFC than spend a second season in Holland, unless it's with one of the teams playing in Europe as well. Any chance that Pep could help sort a loan to the Bundesliga? Hertha Berlin, Mainz, Leverkusen or Moenchengladbach all in Europe, but there are plenty of other decent teams where he could do well.

wo

All fair points BXL, i would not be too happy if he went to the second tier either, i don't think he will though.
Big summer for the lad.

 

[SlimShadyRus]

Personally I think Byrne should take Delph's place in the squad (he can pass and shoot and he's got loads of attitude - I think Pep will like him). If we send him on loan again a promoted Girona would be great, but Spanish second tier not so much. I'd rather see him to go to NYCFC than spend a second season in Holland, unless it's with one of the teams playing in Europe as well. Any chance that Pep could help sort a loan to the Bundesliga? Hertha Berlin, Mainz, Leverkusen or Moenchengladbach all in Europe, but there are plenty of other decent teams where he could do well.


wo

Netherlands is actually better than NYCFC although I would want neither of these for Jack.

 

[leighton]

No matter what happens Jack will have some options open to him after his spell with Cambuur. So I hope the club and Pep get him the right club if it is another loan out just feel he will be a even better player with 1 more season of games behind him. I feel he has more chance of getting game time in European leagues more so than the championship were his talent will be wasted. He is only 20 so can he and when he makes the jump in full time with the squad will be seen but this summer will be huge for Jack. It wouldnt surprise me if he stays and fights for a place as he can be they type of player to spark things off. Maybe Pep could mold Jack into a Alonso type of player but younger lol.

 

[pee dubya]

No matter what happens Jack will have some options open to him after his spell with Cambuur. So I hope the club and Pep get him the right club if it is another loan out just feel he will be a even better player with 1 more season of games behind him. I feel he has more chance of getting game time in European leagues more so than the championship were his talent will be wasted. He is only 20 so can he and when he makes the jump in full time with the squad will be seen but this summer will be huge for Jack. It wouldnt surprise me if he stays and fights for a place as he can be they type of player to spark things off. Maybe Pep could mold Jack into a Alonso type of player but younger lol.

From what i've seen of him, he's more like Thiago than Alonso (that goes to Aleix Garcia).

Would like to see Byrne in the first team squad full time next season, then if he doesn't get enough game time he can always go on loan in January. 6 months training under Guardiola can't do too much harm.

 

[WNRH]

All of Jack Byrne's actions vs PSV.

I think Byrne is a talented midfielder but that video is awful. How many times does he give the ball away. I hate videos like this, fans cream over them due to one good pass, they seem to forget all the bad passes and lost possession they do.

He's had a great year though for his first loan and he should continue to progress with a team in the Championship.

 

[km09]

Wigan would be perfect for him, if the club could sort that. could get himself settled and wouldnt have to move when returning to city

 

[Neville Kneville]

I think Byrne is a talented midfielder but that video is awful. How many times does he give the ball away. I hate videos like this, fans cream over them due to one good pass, they seem to forget all the bad passes and lost possession they do.

He's had a great year though for his first loan and he should continue to progress with a team in the Championship.

Less than Silva or DeBruyne do, in a typical game, surrounded by stars, is the answer.

Caught in possession a couple of times, are the only mistakes. The others are passes trying to hit runners. This team are shit. He is playing on his own & the player tasked with creating everything. He can't just recycle the ball & pass sideways, he has to try stuff. Nothing wrong with that performance at all vs one of their best teams.

 

[SlimShadyRus]

I think Byrne is a talented midfielder but that video is awful. How many times does he give the ball away. I hate videos like this, fans cream over them due to one good pass, they seem to forget all the bad passes and lost possession they do.

He's had a great year though for his first loan and he should continue to progress with a team in the Championship.

You are illogical. Have you even watched the video before saying it's awful? It's neutral.

 

[Yates]

If you're looking for a potential European side then Rangers could be a possibility if they win the Scottish Cup final, of course this could hamper the relationship with Celtic or you could try them for the loan. Just feel Rangers would see him get more game time.

 

[Tugay One Cup]

If you're looking for a potential European side then Rangers could be a possibility if they win the Scottish Cup final, of course this could hamper the relationship with Celtic or you could try them for the loan. Just feel Rangers would see him get more game time.

It's simple then, we could give Celtic first choice on him as a loanee and make them aware that we'll be offering him to Rangers if they turn him down. That way no relations are in jeopardy.

I'm still holding out hope that he will feature for us next season.

 

[Yates]

It's simple then, we could give Celtic first choice on him as a loanee and make them aware that we'll be offering him to Rangers if they turn him down. That way no relations are in jeopardy.

I'm still holding out hope that he will feature for us next season.

Would be a fair way to go about it.

Ye I'd rather see him here and given a shot first too

 

[Gundogan's Moustache]

It's simple then, we could give Celtic first choice on him as a loanee and make them aware that we'll be offering him to Rangers if they turn him down. That way no relations are in jeopardy.

I'm still holding out hope that he will feature for us next season.

But then Celtic could just take him with no intention of playing him to stop Rangers getting him. One of the worst negotiation tactics I've ever heard

 

[Tugay One Cup]

But then Celtic could just take him with no intention of playing him to stop Rangers getting him. One of the worst negotiation tactics I've ever heard

Nothing to do with negotiation tactics as I couldn't care less if Celtic (or Rangers) take him or not. It's about maintaining a healthy relationship with a club by giving them first refusal on one of our players.

 

[leighton]

I think a move to SPL is not worth the hassle a move to Rangers I just cant see happening at all. More chance of him going back out on loan to a Dutch or French club than there. I think he is a guy who needs to playing in a more technical league as his skills are getting better while out on loan in the dutch league some of his passing stats were very high. Shame he missed out on the Ireland squad named O Neill names 1 new player from the League 2 makes you think if he has even checked out Byrne much. So enjoy the summer break off Jack.

 

[Tron Coltrane]

To each his own, but for my part I think a lot of these loan suggestions are beneath Jack's current projection. I know it's a delicate game of when to send them out for more experience and when to bring them home, but if he isn't ready for the equivalent of Kelechi's minutes this season I don't know who is. Pre-season w/ Pep will decide, of course... I just feel like we shouldn't be following the Chelsea path of sending out Lukaku's until they're 100% finished prospects. I'd like to see them make it as far as Jack has this season, with a sense that there's more to come, and bring them home for 10-15 games with the first team the subsequent season.

 

[TonyM]

Not going to the Euros. ONeill is an idiot.

 

[The Footy Diary]

He is in taking a League 2 midfielder ahead of someone who has played well in the Eredivisie.

 

[Gingers Dad]

Won't religion play factor into whether or not he could play for Rangers, or have those days gone?

 

[leighton]

Won't religion play factor into whether or not he could play for Rangers, or have those days gone?

It still does which is sad in this day and age. You got Irish players ruling out a move to Rangers for whatever reason. Some do play for Rangers but those players are few and far between. Only recently has any Republic Of Ireland players have played for Rangers in Jon Daly he got capped at under age level. Also in the current squad is Rob Kiernan who like Daly played under age football for Ireland. Also Alan Judge who has played for the senior Irish team was asked if he would be interested in teaming up with Rangers boss and he stated he would be killed if he went to play for Rangers by his mates. So for any Irish man to play up there you would need balls of steel for Rangers. As they would be slated by all there friends and family it seems.