You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
James McAtee
- Thread starter Shaelumstash
- Start date
Is his contract status a worry, or is this normal for Academy players of his potential to get to this stage?
He’s pretty much the only one who isn’t on a long term contract at the moment. I think there will be a few young players at big clubs who will have looked at someone like Livramento leaving Chelsea to get regular minutes in the PL and be tempted to do the same thing.
Otamendi's Beard
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 11 Jul 2007
- Messages
- 4,407
It would be a bitter pill to swallow if we lost this one.
He'll be worth £50m in a few years and playing for England.
He'll be worth £50m in a few years and playing for England.
Maybe the club hierarchy needs to make a statement along the lines that they believe in the academy
The only statement they can make worth paying attention to is giving them games.
ninjamonkey
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 5 Jun 2009
- Messages
- 22,394
All this clear pathway stuff is just fan talk. We're not going to weaken our side at any point to accommodate potential and I don't believe any player or their people expect that unless they're already up their own arse and have a shit attitude. No club fighting for trophies does that, that's only what you do when you've realistically got no chance of winning.
The challenge for the kids is to turn that potential into reality and force their way in even when there's worlds class players ahead of you, that's what you have to do to make it at the very top.
Other clubs have a habit of signing their top youth on long term contracts just before loaning them out, don't think we do this enough. I know Pep and city have this la masia approach of wanting all our kids to stay here and train in our style with the first team but they all had barca B playing competitive football every week to help them along, the eds just doesn't cut it, we have the likes of Mcatee, Delap, Palmer etc smashing it every week, they've outgrown that already. unless we have a generational superstar like foden capable of slotting straight in we have to bridge the huge gap between eds and first team with good loans. Wasn't there talk of linking up with Swansea recently? That kind of club could do wonders for a few of our better prospects
The challenge for the kids is to turn that potential into reality and force their way in even when there's worlds class players ahead of you, that's what you have to do to make it at the very top.
Other clubs have a habit of signing their top youth on long term contracts just before loaning them out, don't think we do this enough. I know Pep and city have this la masia approach of wanting all our kids to stay here and train in our style with the first team but they all had barca B playing competitive football every week to help them along, the eds just doesn't cut it, we have the likes of Mcatee, Delap, Palmer etc smashing it every week, they've outgrown that already. unless we have a generational superstar like foden capable of slotting straight in we have to bridge the huge gap between eds and first team with good loans. Wasn't there talk of linking up with Swansea recently? That kind of club could do wonders for a few of our better prospects
I don’t blame him if he wants to leave, apart from competing with the first team members, he has to compete with cole palmer to make it at city. The odds are just not in his favor, he is only 18 so he has a lot of time but I guess he wants more now.
The only statement they can make worth paying attention to is giving them games.
Christmas is going to be key when the fixture list gets congested. It's when Garcia first broke through a got a run of games if I recall correctly.
Bernardo can't play every game at the rate he's going, Gundo's been struggling with injuries this season, Foden's still preferred on the wing. We're going to need some support in midfield.
There's an opportunity for him to get some gametime in meaningful fixtures over Dec/Jan and that's going to be telling as to where he currently stands in Pep's plans.
Christmas is going to be key when the fixture list gets congested. It's when Garcia first broke through a got a run of games if I recall correctly.
Bernardo can't play every game at the rate he's going, Gundo's been struggling with injuries this season, Foden's still preferred on the wing. We're going to need some support in midfield.
There's an opportunity for him to get some gametime in meaningful fixtures over Dec/Jan and that's going to be telling as to where he currently stands in Pep's plans.
McAtee absolutely will not start any games for us this season, that’s almost guaranteed.
Centurions
Well-Known Member
Who said he wants to leave? He's also not competing with Cole Palmer as they play in different positions.I don’t blame him if he wants to leave, apart from competing with the first team members, he has to compete with cole palmer to make it at city. The odds are just not in his favor, he is only 18 so he has a lot of time but I guess he wants more now.
I’m assuming if Brighton have offered us £8 mil they will have had some encouragement from McAtee’s camp. Be gutted if we lost him he Is the most promising youngster to come through the academy since foden imo.Who said he wants to leave? He's also not competing with Cole Palmer as they play in different positions.
Bargaining chip for his new contract....I’m assuming if Brighton have offered us £8 mil they will have had some encouragement from McAtee’s camp. Be gutted if we lost him he Is the most promising youngster to come through the academy since foden imo.
Agent - Sorry 25k isn't good enough Brighton will pay double that.
Txiki - £35k?
Agent - Done.
Cheadle_hulmeBlue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 27 Oct 2012
- Messages
- 19,326
Unfortunately I wouldn’t be surprised if he went, especially if he wants first team football. There is no clear pathway for him at the minute.
he’d be great under potter, but it would be such a waste seeing potentially one of the best young players we’ve ever had leaving…
I think this is going to be an issue as we have too many good young players stuck in reserve football
he’d be great under potter, but it would be such a waste seeing potentially one of the best young players we’ve ever had leaving…
I think this is going to be an issue as we have too many good young players stuck in reserve football
Doubt his motivation is money right now. If he makes it at city, we would pay him more than brighton can dream of.Bargaining chip for his new contract....
Agent - Sorry 25k isn't good enough Brighton will pay double that.
Txiki - £35k?
Agent - Done.
His motivation doesn't have to be money, he's pays his agent to do that.Doubt his motivation is money right now. If he makes it at city, we would pay him more than brighton can dream of.
Well maybe he doesn’t want to leave, but the reality is that he was offered a new contract and he has not yet made up his mind if he is signing for us long term and I doubt brighton have decided to bid 8 million on an 18 year old with 30 minutes if he is not open to the move.Who said he wants to leave? He's also not competing with Cole Palmer as they play in different positions.
I said Cole Palmer because they are both trying to break into the team, doubt they can break into the team together even if they play different positions, there is barely space in the squad for an extra player. Sure McAtee might be the one who makes it but the odds are not in his favor
decmancity
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 Nov 2010
- Messages
- 14,600
My concern is that clubs dont bid unless they have had encouragement from the player themselves.
I am pretty sure we can pay him whatever brighton is offering right now. McAtee has only played 30 minutes of senior football btw, so I don’t know why you think brighton would offer him big money.His motivation doesn't have to be money, he's pays his agent to do that.
Contract ends in 2023 according to google? I guess spend the rest of the season convincing him to sign. If not if we get a good value buy back clause in summer, its probably a better arrangement than letting him walk for free at the end of next season.