James Milner

Dr Jacoby said:
de niro said:
still reckon he's a centre mid man.

In a team with title aspirations? Hell no.

We need him to support Zabba as the Everton left looks like their most dangerous. That and getting tight on Lukaku [which he doesn't seem to like]. A good scrape on his achilles should do it.
 
coleridge said:
Dr Jacoby said:
de niro said:
still reckon he's a centre mid man.

In a team with title aspirations? Hell no.

We need him to support Zabba as the Everton left looks like their most dangerous. That and getting tight on Lukaku [which he doesn't seem to like]. A good scrape on his achilles should do it.
The one thing you can never question is his commitment. The lad just runs, and runs, and runs.
 
He is a typically British player. Commitment can't be faulted, therefore fans tend to overlook his more limited abilities on the ball. Then you have 'johnny foreigner', aka garcia or demichelis, who get slagged off something rotten for the odd slip up and their perceived lack of effort.

I actually think that you need a blend of players, with different attributes.
 
put in a massive effort, as usual, but didn't play particularly well. He did what was needed to be done.
 
Yesterday was the perfect game for Milner. Away to a hard working team with mainly British players is the game for Milner.

Home to bottom of the table Sunderland where you need that extra bit of guile isn't the game for him.

Next weekend away to Everton - Milner must start.

I thought he was very good yesterday. He works unbelievably hard and helps the team so much in those sort of games.
 
I thought he was exceptional in the first 30 minutes when we were at our best. Workrate was high and he was really putting pressure on them. Slowed a bit in the last hour, but he did a tremendous job of closing out and not giving Palace time on the ball early and it helped us to really pin them back and probe.
 
ErnieBilko said:
He is a typically British player. Commitment can't be faulted, therefore fans tend to overlook his more limited abilities on the ball. Then you have 'johnny foreigner', aka garcia or demichelis, who get slagged off something rotten for the odd slip up and their perceived lack of effort.

I actually think that you need a blend of players, with different attributes.

Those two generally get slagged of for being slow as fuck.
 
Prestwich_Blue said:
stonerblue said:
Yet another shit game from Jimmy. Get rid..
Thought he was good yesterday.

Yup decent assits and covered lots of ground

We have the creative players but like any top team we also need players whom do lots of the dirty side of the game to allow the other players to perform
 
Think he is a top quality squad player who can miss 10 games through not getting picked but then plays like his life depends on it when he gets the nod. I agree with the posters who say technically he's not up there with the likes of Silva, Nasri, YaYa etc., but then we already know this; what he does bring is grit, determination and a personal character which means he never, ever hides, even when he does fuck up.

Another point that I think gets missed is that Milner never really has the chance to find any continuity or rhythm because of his sporadic game time. Just like Dzeko struggles when he isn't playing, I think this could also be applied to Jimmy, although his body language doesn't give anything away, which is a credit to his professionalism.
 
malg said:
coleridge said:
Dr Jacoby said:
In a team with title aspirations? Hell no.

We need him to support Zabba as the Everton left looks like their most dangerous. That and getting tight on Lukaku [which he doesn't seem to like]. A good scrape on his achilles should do it.
The one thing you can never question is his commitment. The lad just runs, and runs, and runs.

So does Forrest Gump.

I don't know how anyone could say he had "a great game" yesterday. He can be so much better than that.
 
Chippy_boy said:
malg said:
coleridge said:
We need him to support Zabba as the Everton left looks like their most dangerous. That and getting tight on Lukaku [which he doesn't seem to like]. A good scrape on his achilles should do it.
The one thing you can never question is his commitment. The lad just runs, and runs, and runs.

So does Forrest Gump.

I don't know how anyone could say he had "a great game" yesterday. He can be so much better than that.


I like Milner but he has been poor recently....
 
If someone with a fancy foreign name had produced the turn to get away from England's best left back before picking out Dzeko brilliantly for our second then it'd have been shown over and over again on every highlights show going. As it was Milner I think the commentator merely noted that he did well to get away from Baines.
 
kenzie115 said:
If someone with a fancy foreign name had produced the turn to get away from England's best left back before picking out Dzeko brilliantly for our second then it'd have been shown over and over again on every highlights show going. As it was Milner I think the commentator merely noted that he did well to get away from Baines.

Agreed.
Problem with Milner is that although you could always expect him to run himself to the ground,
he is that kind of hit or miss player.
At times, he looks like not being able to provide a decent cross or pass even to save his own life.
 
pride in battle said:
Chippy_boy said:
malg said:
The one thing you can never question is his commitment. The lad just runs, and runs, and runs.

So does Forrest Gump.

I don't know how anyone could say he had "a great game" yesterday. He can be so much better than that.


I like Milner but he has been poor recently....

Crossed the ball for Dzekos goal.. passed to Ferna who passed to Nasri who set up Dzeko goal.
did his bit yesterday.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top