Neville Kneville
Well-Known Member
BigOscar said:If you see the main purpose of pre season as a shop window for getting rid of your cast offs, then I guess it went ok, but from a point of view of giving players a chance to fight for a place, it was a complet non-starter. We're supposed to be preparing for our season, not running a job fair for our undesireables. It's not as if we were trying to get rid of complete unknowns, who's buyers were going to make their decisions off of how good they were in pre season, were talking about first team players. In my opinion, pre season should be about getting the players you intend to play in the upcoming year up to match fitness, while giving the more promising kids a chance to show that they can make the step up. If a player has no chance of being in your plans for the year, then I see no point in wasting pre season time on them.Neville Kneville said:BigOscar said:One of a few players who needs to get given a proper go in preseason, playing proper amounts of games alongside proper players, instead of the balls up that was this years pre-season. Despite all our players being away at the world cup, we still failed to give our relevant young players a chance, instead wasting time on people we knew were leaving or had no significant future at the club, like Richards, Sinclair, Nastasic and Boyata. The only ones got given a real chance were Kelechi and Zuculini, one of whom it looked like we had intention of giving a chance this year as we'd already decided to loan him, while the other still hasn't even officially signed for us 6 months later. Fucking shambles.
Next year we will have a good amount of young players who could be challenging for a first team squad place, so we need to actually give them a chance to show they're up to it.
I don't understand what you mean We tried out Nastasic, Rekik, Denayer & Boyata. Rekik was slow & crap, Denayer showed promise but was raw & clearly not ready but impressed Celtic, Nastasic bottlled out of several headers & blew his chance, Boyata had a few clumsy moments but was bigger stronger faster & more keen to fight than the other two, and better on the ball, so got the job.
Iheanacho showed he isn't far away, Zucculini showed possible suitors he was worth a loan & Sinclair/Richards/Guidetti got chance to try & impress possible loan/buyers.
I think it was a brilliant job. We got jobs for everybody but Sinclair, & had a contest between the cbs which Boyata won. Nastasic was also offered moves but turned them down.
Boyata didn't win some contest to be our 4th defender, he was clearly already decided to be our 4th choice CB for the year, otherwise we wouldn't of given him the new contract. Nastasic was already being offered around and told to fuck off, while Rekik and Denayer were never given a serious chance to stake a claim. Denayer got about two halves of football, while Rekik got maybe 3 or 4, mostly playing at RCB to accomodate his partners preference, where he'd clearly never played before and looked completely lost (as left footed defenders usually seem to when you make them play there). Neither was given a platform to actually stake a claim, they both clearly had loans in the pipeline. Boyata got it because he was the one who we didn't care if he wasted a year only playing once or twice.
None of the young players were given a chance to stake a claim at all. Zuculini was outstanding and still got farmed out, despite our lack of CM options, so he clearly wasn't playing for a place. Fofana, Ntcham, Ambrose, Glendon and the rest of the EDS lads who might of been able to show they were worthy of cup squad or two never got any significant time to prove anything. If they can't get a chance in pre season, then how can you expect them to get a chance in games that matter?
None of those lads were anywhere near it. It would have just been a run out for them, not a serious trial. Not a chance in hell Glendon could have played his position in a first team game then, Ambrose was half the size he is now, Ntcham has only this season started to show maturity, which Fofana hasn't yet in a City shirt, but may be for Fulham.
All 4 of Rekik, Nastasic, Denayer & Boyata, were potential candidates for a job. Rekik just proved he's nowhere near it either in the air or on the ground, Denayer played some really nice stuff but was obviously not ready, Nastasic was fine until asked to defend a tough situation then bottled out, Boyata fought really hard to get the job, & got it.
The EDS kids are now getting close to being serious contenders & next pre season, I'm confident some will play. i imagine Denayer & possibly Rekik will as well unless we agree to them staying where they are.
Imo some of the kids should be in the squad for next weekend as they have improved in every aspect since the summer.