John Guidetti

[Don Karleone]

A Villa mate of mine just asked me how good Guidetti is as he's heard they may be in for him.

 

[Falastur]

The Mirror are saying that Rosler has used his City contacts to set up a loan move for Guidetti to Wigan in Jan.

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/transfer-news/manchester-city-transfer-news-john-2974154" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/ ... hn-2974154</a>?

 

[FantasyIreland]

An opportunity to learn from Uwe would be great for John.Wigan are playing some good stuff and he'd surely be guaranteed football at a level that can hopefully prepare him for the step up to the Prem.

 

[NQCitizen]

Sounds good, he needs minutes and we have four strikers who are all better then him. Hopefully he can find some form, we will probably then sell Dzeko in the summer and he will come in and replace him.

Aguero - obviously better, but injured at the moment.
Negredo - again, clearly a better player
Jovetic - a better player, but i think we'll be lucky to get 10 games out of him by the end of the season
Dzeko - I'd say the jury's still out on Dzeko being better than Guidetti. Dzeko's knack of occasionallly scoring brilliant/vital goals doesn't really make up for his knack of squandering chance after chance. We'd have to see guidetti play before we could say for sure

Edin Dzeko was Bundesliga top scorer, the top scorer in world cup qualification and has one of the best goals per minute stats in the league ever.

I know we don't rate him on Bluemoon, but that certainly puts him a league ahead of Guidetti.

 

[Ray78]

No disrespect to either Uwe Rosler or Wigan but he should be going to a club in a higher division. Malaga or Real Betis might be a good experience for the lad.

 

[MillionDollarDream]

Sounds good, he needs minutes and we have four strikers who are all better then him. Hopefully he can find some form, we will probably then sell Dzeko in the summer and he will come in and replace him.

Aguero - obviously better, but injured at the moment.
Negredo - again, clearly a better player
Jovetic - a better player, but i think we'll be lucky to get 10 games out of him by the end of the season
Dzeko - I'd say the jury's still out on Dzeko being better than Guidetti. Dzeko's knack of occasionallly scoring brilliant/vital goals doesn't really make up for his knack of squandering chance after chance. We'd have to see guidetti play before we could say for sure

Edin Dzeko was Bundesliga top scorer, the top scorer in world cup qualification and has one of the best goals per minute stats in the league ever.

I know we don't rate him on Bluemoon, but that certainly puts him a league ahead of Guidetti.

Also while John had a good record with Feyenoord, Jose Alitidore had a good Dutch scoring record with AZ and Bony is struggling at the moment with Swansea. John can be one of them or Luis Suarez. Hopefully the latter.

 

[FantasyIreland]

I disagree,a move to such a level is ideal for his current rehabilitation.He hasn't played decent football for a very long time,a spell in a more physical,but still technical,league is perfect imo.

At a Prem club I think he'd currently struggle for playing time.

 

[mgreenz97]

Sounds good, he needs minutes and we have four strikers who are all better then him. Hopefully he can find some form, we will probably then sell Dzeko in the summer and he will come in and replace him.

Aguero - obviously better, but injured at the moment.
Negredo - again, clearly a better player
Jovetic - a better player, but i think we'll be lucky to get 10 games out of him by the end of the season
Dzeko - I'd say the jury's still out on Dzeko being better than Guidetti. Dzeko's knack of occasionallly scoring brilliant/vital goals doesn't really make up for his knack of squandering chance after chance. We'd have to see guidetti play before we could say for sure

Edin Dzeko was Bundesliga top scorer, the top scorer in world cup qualification and has one of the best goals per minute stats in the league ever.

I know we don't rate him on Bluemoon, but that certainly puts him a league ahead of Guidetti.

I don't think his record from years ago in another league is significant, and statistics can be amazingly misleading.
He was actually the second top goalscorer in the world cup qualifiers behind van persie (still a great achievement on paper), but what that doesn't tell us is that 5 of his goals came against Lichenstein, a team that has won 10 games in the 15 years it has existed. I can't say that Guidetti is better than Dzeko, solely because Guidetti hasn't played in over a year and hasn't played for City at all, but I think that Guidetti would if given the chance, actually give a shit about the team.

 

[JasminBosnia]

Aguero - obviously better, but injured at the moment.
Negredo - again, clearly a better player
Jovetic - a better player, but i think we'll be lucky to get 10 games out of him by the end of the season
Dzeko - I'd say the jury's still out on Dzeko being better than Guidetti. Dzeko's knack of occasionallly scoring brilliant/vital goals doesn't really make up for his knack of squandering chance after chance. We'd have to see guidetti play before we could say for sure

Edin Dzeko was Bundesliga top scorer, the top scorer in world cup qualification and has one of the best goals per minute stats in the league ever.

I know we don't rate him on Bluemoon, but that certainly puts him a league ahead of Guidetti.

I don't think his record from years ago in another league is significant, and statistics can be amazingly misleading.
He was actually the second top goalscorer in the world cup qualifiers behind van persie (still a great achievement on paper), but what that doesn't tell us is that 5 of his goals came against Lichenstein, a team that has won 10 games in the 15 years it has existed. I can't say that Guidetti is better than Dzeko, solely because Guidetti hasn't played in over a year and hasn't played for City at all, but I think that Guidetti would if given the chance, actually give a shit about the team.

OMFG. Some of you are the most delusional fans in the world.

 

[Super David Silva 21]

I'd prefer him to stay over here if he is loaned out, wigan could be the right move for the lads future.