S
S
Summerbuzz
Guest
Right now, Pep could buy John O'Shea and I'd be okay with it.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Jonny Evans
- Thread starter Tanzeylee
- Start date
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
citytilllidie
Well-Known Member
Buy who you want Pep. Evans is better than The Mangler
blue ranger
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 1 Oct 2008
- Messages
- 2,718
Buy who you want Pep. Evans is better than The Mangler
Imagine the mangler in a big champions league game. Don’t think Jonny Evans is the answer for us, but he is a better back up to Stones and Otamendi any day of the week, despite that seeming to upset people. We all want the mangler to do well, but last nights game at Leicester showed he just isn’t goody enough for this team.
Dave Ewing's Back 'eader
Well-Known Member
Imagine the mangler in a big champions league game. Don’t think Jonny Evans is the answer for us, but he is a better back up to Stones and Otamendi any day of the week, despite that seeming to upset people. We all want the mangler to do well, but last nights game at Leicester showed he just isn’t goody enough for this team.
Neither JFE nor The Mangler will hold down berth No1 in Pep's team. We all know that! But gimme The Mangler over JFE any day, night or hour of the week. Neither are Franco Baresi but if we end up in the CL final and Otters, Kompers, or Stonesy are unavailable my vote would go to The Mangler over JFE.
Kompany’s continuing injuries have changed the whole landscape of a CB acquisition in my opinion.
Evans would have been a decent 4th choice to come in for the cup games and if we were really stretched for options defensively, however I think Pep will want a world class option to replace Vinny now, of whom can also challenge John and Nico.
Evans would have been a decent 4th choice to come in for the cup games and if we were really stretched for options defensively, however I think Pep will want a world class option to replace Vinny now, of whom can also challenge John and Nico.
kaz7
Well-Known Member
There are a lot of arguments for and against Evans.
I think it boils down to a cost/benefit analysis - what does Evans actually give the squad in relation to how much he would cost? Would he be first choice now? Would he be first choice at any point in the next 3 years? Does he have untapped upside? Is he significantly better then the backups that we've got? Is he available at a decent price?
For me, its a 'no' for all of the above. This isn't to say he's a bad player (because he's not) or that he wouldn't improve the squad (because he probably would). I don't care he played for United. I do care that he'd be 3rd choice (at best), likely wouldn't be here in 3-4 years considering his age, and his value is inflated coming from an English side. For me there are much better ways to spend the 30 million.
I think it boils down to a cost/benefit analysis - what does Evans actually give the squad in relation to how much he would cost? Would he be first choice now? Would he be first choice at any point in the next 3 years? Does he have untapped upside? Is he significantly better then the backups that we've got? Is he available at a decent price?
For me, its a 'no' for all of the above. This isn't to say he's a bad player (because he's not) or that he wouldn't improve the squad (because he probably would). I don't care he played for United. I do care that he'd be 3rd choice (at best), likely wouldn't be here in 3-4 years considering his age, and his value is inflated coming from an English side. For me there are much better ways to spend the 30 million.
Cheadle_hulmeBlue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 27 Oct 2012
- Messages
- 16,890
There are a lot of arguments for and against Evans.
I think it boils down to a cost/benefit analysis - what does Evans actually give the squad in relation to how much he would cost? Would he be first choice now? Would he be first choice at any point in the next 3 years? Does he have untapped upside? Is he significantly better then the backups that we've got? Is he available at a decent price?
For me, its a 'no' for all of the above. This isn't to say he's a bad player (because he's not) or that he wouldn't improve the squad (because he probably would). I don't care he played for United. I do care that he'd be 3rd choice (at best), likely wouldn't be here in 3-4 years considering his age, and his value is inflated coming from an English side. For me there are much better ways to spend the 30 million.
isn't that why we want him though ? as a back up. hes not coming here as first choice. he would be an experienced squad player, good on the ball and a leader. hes miles then mangala for me as well.
W
W
worsleyweb
Guest
His dad is the biggest rag there is. On that basis I am out.
isn't that why we want him though ? as a back up. hes not coming here as first choice. he would be an experienced squad player, good on the ball and a leader. hes miles then mangala for me as well.
Right - I personally think you could find a younger & cheaper 3rd choice. I think he's better than Mangala, but I'm not sure about 30m better.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.