I think Southgate did an excellent job when he first came in. He rebuilt morale on and off the field. But football has changed in the last ten years and he has stood still. If you don't change with the times you go backwards.
He's been desperate to "do a Greece" since he first took the job, and you can't really blame him for trying, can you (circa 2016).
But the opportunity for that was 3 years ago against Italy and the team (on and off the pitch) collectively shit the bed and blew it. For whatever reasons, Southgate and England haven't advanced, haven't stumbled across a new tactical system in their limited time together, he's listened to the biased agenda driven media tactical suggestions and they've failed, and we've stagnated. Badly.
That's not a good look for illustrating a manager's ability.
The bit that sticks in me is that when he started off, when he first took the job, he started with a strong statement. New man, new rules, and it's my way from now on.
He didn't hang about, he set his stall out early by dropping many of the old guard under-performing but still mainstay England regulars and picked lads, young hungry lads, to be their replacements.
He talked about 'merit' and 'form' and 'if you're good enough you
will get your opportunity'; "What you've done in the past, and what your name is, isn't how I'm going to be selecting my England squads" is a quote I've just made up which has the feel of what his attitude was back then.
Fucking blah-blah-blah is what it turned out to be.
Luke fucking Shaw and, let's face it, we all know that if GBH Harry had been in the same injured situation as Shaw he'd have been there too.
Why haven't we got a trustable Left winger?
Where's the young Left-back who's being given his chance?
Where's the exciting attacking lad who was the only shining light in Chelsea's season?
AND (back on the topic of the thread:)...
Why is the PL player of the year the one being sacrificed in favour of an "off form" pin-up player?
Bellingham is fucking shocking!
"Possible fucking Balon D'Or winner", cause after last year's debacle of a decision that's a huge accolade.
Is the media backlash if it isn't a success, clouding Southgate's judgement? Or is he, as the majority believe, actually clueless?