Tugay One Cup
Well-Known Member
Hardly an upgrade for him if you compare to other suitors like City :)
Depends on whether he wants to play every week for Villa or be a rotation option for a bigger club. I can see the pros and cons of both.
Hardly an upgrade for him if you compare to other suitors like City :)
Starting at Villa won’t get him into England imo. If he’s as interested in City as some say, then it’s a long term move. Villa doesn’t seem like a long term moveDepends on whether he wants to play every week for Villa or be a rotation option for a bigger club. I can see the pros and cons of both.
If he wanted to go down that route then surely Newcastle would be a better option for him?Depends on whether he wants to play every week for Villa or be a rotation option for a bigger club. I can see the pros and cons of both.
Apparently it’s between 35m before and 25m after. So either way he can go. But I can’t see him leaving if they are still in the PLSo are we all hoping for Leeds to get relegated so that we can get him cheap?
So are we all hoping for Leeds to get relegated so that we can get him cheap?
I think it’s all about long term prospect. He seems like the dude who’s in something for the long ride. Kalvin are close buds to Jack for example and Leeds wouldn’t be pissed off if he went too City rather than Villa or Newcastle. I think he’s gonna make a decision based on sensible progress and long term success.If he wanted to go down that route then surely Newcastle would be a better option for him?
If he wanted to go down that route then surely Newcastle would be a better option for him?
I think most would be happy to pay the higher price if it ensured Leeds were relegated.So are we all hoping for Leeds to get relegated so that we can get him cheap?
Only reason for Leeds to not be relegated is to rid the PL of the herpes that is Burnley.Why not.
I think most would be happy to pay the higher price if it ensured Leeds were relegated.
So are we all hoping for Leeds to get relegated so that we can get him cheap?
I think some on here would be happy to chip in £35m just to see Leeds relegated. Getting a player at the same time would just be a bonus.So are we all hoping for Leeds to get relegated so that we can get him cheap?
We hardly ever play with 2 DMs. If we do get Phillips, it can only be as cover for Rodri. If we get to the CL final next season (don't laugh), and we had a fully fit squad (again, don't laugh) to pick from, and Phillips, not Kilroy, was here, no way would he be in the starting XI.Rodri is the best DM in the world... Ofc Phillips isnt better or starting over Rodri. BUT Phillips is a very good backup to Rodri, so we can rest Rodri more often.
With Rodri being our best and unflinching DM this season, Fernandinho still got 32 games... even as backup, Phillips would get around 30 games. And Rodri getting more rest I’m guessing he’d get even more gametime. So that’s not an issue and Southgate would love to see Phillips develop under Pep for the WC.We hardly ever play with 2 DMs. If we do get Phillips, it can only be as cover for Rodri. If we get to the CL final next season (don't laugh), and we had a fully fit squad (again, don't laugh) to pick from, and Phillips, not Kilroy, was here, no way would he be in the starting XI.
Rodri needs a strong back up so he can be rested, has suffered from being overplayed at times. Whether that’s Phillips or someone else, it can only help him, he has probably played as many games as any other outfield player since he signedWe hardly ever play with 2 DMs. If we do get Phillips, it can only be as cover for Rodri. If we get to the CL final next season (don't laugh), and we had a fully fit squad (again, don't laugh) to pick from, and Phillips, not Kilroy, was here, no way would he be in the starting XI.
There is a clause regardless of outcome today apparently, so city are never going up to 50milPhilips at £35mil release clause is a great deal and a smart purchase all things considered
If we have to spend the £50mil/60mil Leeds probably want then it's 100% a non start
Well... Newcastle, Spurs, United and Villa are all linked. But would he get Pep or CL football with either? Spurs, perhaps. But players like Grealish etc value going into CL in their career and playing under pep even if they aren’t guaranteed startersAnother busy summer is inevitable under Steven Gerrard. The Villa head coach wants at least two other major signings, with Leeds midfielder Kalvin Phillips a leading target.
![]()
Inside Aston Villa's transfer war room as Steven Gerrard prepares for a busy summer
Gerrard will be an influential figure in the recruitment process, with Leeds midfielder Kalvin Phillips a leading targetwww.telegraph.co.uk
Apparently Villa wants him.