Kompany-citys best ever centre back?

[ConnorD110]

in my time as a blue , i have seen no centre half better, bear in mind in 16 though

 

[the old abbey]

on a slight tangent,the greatest captain ever of this club was ROY PAUL.

 

[Damocles]

Think he's been a little suspect the last few games, but a decent player. Overrated by some, but has had a great season

 

[Smoothy B.]

Kompany is cetainly playing very well at the moment. To be honest though, he has a long long way to go to match the caveman Dave Watson. I remember him covered in blood lifting the cup in 76. A real blue hero. Wasnt it Big Mal (RIP) that sold him?

 

[ColinBellsjockstrap]

Bet he has a shittun tomorrow now....!...potentially he's got the lot plus a wise head on young shoulders.

My top 3 for now....

Dave Watson

Mick Doyle

Tommy Booth

George Heslop

Yes another vote for Big George..........RIP.

 

[levets]

The best centre back I've seen in a city shirt was Dave Watson but for me Kompany is better. Maybe to early to say but I think he's the best I've seen.

Adam, how old are you mate? It might help to justify what you just said. Kompany nowhere near the best ever.

 

[kippaxblue76]

Dave Watson for me by good way, Vinnie has some distance to go to be as good as him. Watson was a colossus.

 

[MikeF]

Think he's been a little suspect the last few games, but a decent player. Overrated by some, but has had a great season

Seconded, been a bit iffy of late for me

 

[sniff]

The best centre back I've seen in a city shirt was Dave Watson but for me Kompany is better. Maybe to early to say but I think he's the best I've seen.

Adam, how old are you mate? It might help to justify what you just said. Kompany nowhere near the best ever.

im 29 so never saw the others people have mentioned, but i dont think he is as good as Van Buyten.

 

[malg]

Not read the whole thread as I am half cut, but has anyone mentioned Morrison yet?