Kylian Mbappe

Status
Not open for further replies.
He is a poacher no doubt but he has to develop his overall game if he is to ever play in a Pep side. Shit even Kun has had to evolve his game and change to fit in this season.

He isnt going to play and he needs to go unfortunately with a loan my preferred option but its looking like we will just sell.

As for Hart and Mangala? Forget it, not going to happen, ever.
I know it won't happen, but didn't Mangala and Otamendi played together at Porto? We should try it.
As for poachers, wasn't Inzaghi the best of it? And didn t he had some kind of CL goal scoring record? We should have one in the squad.
As for Aguero he keep changing his game his all career: from a winger, to a second striker to a lonely striker. He is that good. For me he is the best in the world.
 
I know it won't happen, but didn't Mangala and Otamendi played together at Porto? We should try it.
As for poachers, wasn't Inzaghi the best of it? And didn t he had some kind of CL goal scoring record? We should have one in the squad.
As for Aguero he keep changing his game his all career: from a winger, to a second striker to a lonely striker. He is that good. For me he is the best in the world.

I think Mbappe will be a worlbeater in the future, but I don't think he would instantly replace Aguero, in the Premier League, playing cf, in the systems Pep has mostly been using.

He would suddenly find himself playing with his back to goal, getting the shit kicked out of him. That's not his usual situation. Aguero & Jesus are way ahead of him in that area.

Imo, he would play with at least one of those two, maybe both, like Henry.

Speaking of Inzaghi, our own kid Unal, is more like that kind of poacher, than any of them, imo.
 
I think Mbappe will be a worlbeater in the future, but I don't think he would instantly replace Aguero, in the Premier League, playing cf, in the systems Pep has mostly been using.

He would suddenly find himself playing with his back to goal, getting the shit kicked out of him. That's not his usual situation. Aguero & Jesus are way ahead of him in that area.

Imo, he would play with at least one of those two, maybe both, like Henry.

Speaking of Inzaghi, our own kid Unal, is more like that kind of poacher, than any of them, imo.
I see Unal more of a Dzeko.
As for Mbappe, I am not as excited as others about him. Let s wait 2-3 seasons before calling him world class.
Everyone here is calling him the new ballon d'or, but what happened with Sane, Silva and Jesus? They were supposed to be so as well. Not to mention de Bruyne which, in my opinion, is different class.
 
The last goal in a 4-0 rout and a goal against Celtic, don't want to do Iheanacho down but context is needed on that stat.

11 mins vs Borussia - scored
90 mins vs Celtic - scored
10 mins vs Monaco when 3-1 down - didnt score

Only opportunities he was given in the champions league.
 
I see Unal more of a Dzeko.
As for Mbappe, I am not as excited as others about him. Let s wait 2-3 seasons before calling him world class.
Everyone here is calling him the new ballon d'or, but what happened with Sane, Silva and Jesus? They were supposed to be so as well. Not to mention de Bruyne which, in my opinion, is different class.

Unal is a lot more sneaky & less static than Dzeko (with better technique).

Imo Mbappe is the current top young talent out there, & whether it transpires that he maintains it & improves, or not, there is no option of 'waiting a few years' because he's gone then.

Anyone who wants him, has to put their cards on the table now, even if he's staying at Monaco, because the kind of money rags put into Martial, means that the going rate for someone much better, will be that high. Real are even breaking the bank for 16 year olds.

We have done brilliantly with Jesus & Sane, as imo they are right up there, but to do the same in the future will be difficult.
 
11 mins vs Borussia - scored
90 mins vs Celtic - scored
10 mins vs Monaco when 3-1 down - didnt score

Only opportunities he was given in the champions league.

Exactly, far too small a sample size to draw any conclusions from.
 
Yes, I know he is probably gone but I rate him very highly. As for Mbappe, time will say. Iheanacho came straight from Nigeria, took the EDS by storm, and immediately proved himself in PL. People seem to forget just how good he is. Mbappe scored in Ligue 1, in a team that dominates all the opponents, and most of the goals were team play. He doesn't seem to create his goals, let s say like Aguero at the same age. And he scored in CL as well, but wouldn't Iheanacho have scored if he had been played as well? I think he would.

Please don't compare Iheanacho to Mbappe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.