League Cup Final - Hart or Pantilimon?

[i kne albert davy]

Pantillimon,he's been great for us in this comp and deserves a final at wembley,if we cant put trust in our reserve keeper then we should take all trust away from our reserve players too..
pot kettle and all that..

Really he wasn't to great against Villa trust me.

 

[Mr. Aguia]

strongest team that means Hart.

Not sure where you have been mate, but Hart is a shadow of his former self. At least you know that Pantilimon will give you a good 7/10 every game. Hart can do a 10/10 save one minute and then hesitate and flap at a corner the next.

Hart is still far and away the better keeper even when he was at his worst. Hart has been very good of late. IMO should always play our #1 in a cup final. Not worried about Pant's "feelings getting hurt".

 

[dctid]

why would be we do anything other than put out our strongest team - a win and its a fantastic springboard for the FA and LEague lose and it put us under pressure

Its an important game next week

 

[mammutly]

If we'd have been playing the rags, I'd have said give Pants the chance. But Sunderland are a good side so it's definitely Hart for me.

 

[TGR]

I would have no problem with Pants being in goal at Wembley. He won't let anyone down.

 

[1961_vintage]

Chance to put right at least one of the fuck-ups of last season's cup final.

Pantaloons in goal for me.

 

[bumbleblue]

Pants.

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Pantilimon.
If nothing else to apologise for mancinis shameful decision to dump him from the fa cup final

Apart from losing, not playing Pants was the worst part of the Final last May. Not certain where Pellers will go with this one, but either would do for me!

 

[Pince]

Hart, England's and City's No 1.
Please...

 

[Burtonblue]

Pants for me.
He has got us there, earned his place and should be given the nod.
Both keepers have strengths and weaknesses. Neither one has shown form that makes him indispensable.