Liverpool thread 2019/20

[Mr Fraser]

Just as a matter of interest, if Liverpool had turned 1 of their draws into a win, and pipped City to the title last year, would that mean that City fans would agree with Klopp being Manager of the year? (all other results being equal)

I actually agree that it should have been Pep, but the difference (in terms of titles) is effectively the lack of a single goal in a crucial match.

Obviously this is entirely a hypothetical as this didn't happen, but I'm curious whether it would have changed opinions.

No

 

[Bill the Blue]

I've been a Liverpool fan for 33 years, although I'm from the Wirral rather than Liverpool itself

Hi Mr Starfish.. 33 years you say.. Bit unlucky that, you've not seen "em win much then have you.. Never mind I've got it on good authority that this year is your year...!!

 

[Start2finish]

Hi Mr Starfish.. 33 years you say.. Bit unlucky that, you've not seen "em win much then have you.. Never mind I've got it on good authority that this year is your year...!!

Once you choose your team, you're stuck with them, good times and bad. What can you do?

Starfish - I like that one

 

[kaz7]

Just as a matter of interest, if Liverpool had turned 1 of their draws into a win, and pipped City to the title last year, would that mean that City fans would agree with Klopp being Manager of the year? (all other results being equal)

I actually agree that it should have been Pep, but the difference (in terms of titles) is effectively the lack of a single goal in a crucial match.

Obviously this is entirely a hypothetical as this didn't happen, but I'm curious whether it would have changed opinions.

No,neither mancini or pellegrinI got manager of the year for winning the title,,klopp is a one trick pony who has you playing hoofball,you blew off the cups to go warm weather training and drew games when you got back,that is not the sign of a good manager,pep went for every single cup and won them all,he is a the very definition of what a top manager should be

 

[Cons Dad]

Just as a matter of interest, if Liverpool had turned 1 of their draws into a win, and pipped City to the title last year, would that mean that City fans would agree with Klopp being Manager of the year? (all other results being equal)

I actually agree that it should have been Pep, but the difference (in terms of titles) is effectively the lack of a single goal in a crucial match.

Obviously this is entirely a hypothetical as this didn't happen, but I'm curious whether it would have changed opinions.

I assume you mean our penalty miss at Klanfield

 

[Start2finish]

No,neither mancini or pellegrinI got manager of the year for winning the title,,klopp is a one trick pony who has you playing hoofball,you blew off the cups to go warm weather training and drew games when you got back,that is not the sign of a good manager,pep went for every single cup and won them all,he is a the very definition of what a top manager should be

I'm not denigrating Peps achievement last year across all competitions. I've said that he deserved FIFA's manager of the year (even if I think its a meaningless media driven title as others have suggested).

But in my hypothetical Klopp would have won both CL and PL in same season. I'm honestly curious why some would still not consider that sufficient?

 

[Bill the Blue]

Once you choose your team, you're stuck with them, good times and bad. What can you do?

Starfish - I like that one

Can I call you Stevie, Stevie?

 

[Start2finish]

I assume you mean our penalty miss at Klanfield

Well I did state if Liverpool had turned one draw into a win and all other results being equal....

 

[citizen_maine]

No,neither mancini or pellegrinI got manager of the year for winning the title,,klopp is a one trick pony who has you playing hoofball,you blew off the cups to go warm weather training and drew games when you got back,that is not the sign of a good manager,pep went for every single cup and won them all,he is a the very definition of what a top manager should be

all?

 

[PannickAtTheDisco]

Well I did state if Liverpool had turned one draw into a win and all other results being equal....

and if we'd turned one of your many offside goals or dives for penalties into the correct decision, we'd need binoculars to see you.