Manchester FACTS

nijinsky's fetlocks said:
Prestwich_Blue said:
No comma needed at all actually. You could use comma INSTEAD of the preposition (Sorry Mr. Fetlocks, this is funny) and you would also use a comma in front of the preposition if it was a long sentence and the phrases either side of could stand as an independent sentence. However "Sorry Mr. Fetlocks.." is not an independent sentence therefore no comma.

Not your day is it mate?

In what way is "Sorry Mr Fetlocks" not an independent sentence?
An independent sentence is a self-contained,complete thought in grammatical terms.
It must contain a noun or noun-phrase and a predicate,that is a verb or adjective that expresses the action or state of being of the subject.
"Mr Fetlocks" in this case is the noun,as a proper name and "Sorry" the predicate.
Therefore the comma after "Fetlocks" is valid.

Absolutely not. To use an adjective like "sorry" as a predicate adjective the subject has to be connected to it by copula (linking verb). You can't substitute the adjective for the verb. Therefore you would be correct if the sentence said "Mr. Fetlocks is sorry, but..."

Look on the bright side. You've learned some Physics, History and English grammar today.
 
We have THE most intelligent and argumenative posters in the solar system.

Oh, and the worlds first section of electrified railwayline for public use ran from Manchester to Alty
 
Prestwich_Blue said:
nijinsky's fetlocks said:
In what way is "Sorry Mr Fetlocks" not an independent sentence?
An independent sentence is a self-contained,complete thought in grammatical terms.
It must contain a noun or noun-phrase and a predicate,that is a verb or adjective that expresses the action or state of being of the subject.
"Mr Fetlocks" in this case is the noun,as a proper name and "Sorry" the predicate.
Therefore the comma after "Fetlocks" is valid.

Absolutely not. To use an adjective like "sorry" as a predicate adjective the subject has to be connected to it by copula (linking verb). You can't substitute the adjective for the verb. Therefore you would be correct if the sentence said "Mr. Fetlocks is sorry, but..."

Look on the bright side. You've learned some Physics, History and English grammar today.


PMSL, how many times has he been routed in the last 48hrs? How humiliating.
 
Prestwich_Blue said:
nijinsky's fetlocks said:
In what way is "Sorry Mr Fetlocks" not an independent sentence?
An independent sentence is a self-contained,complete thought in grammatical terms.
It must contain a noun or noun-phrase and a predicate,that is a verb or adjective that expresses the action or state of being of the subject.
"Mr Fetlocks" in this case is the noun,as a proper name and "Sorry" the predicate.
Therefore the comma after "Fetlocks" is valid.

Absolutely not. To use an adjective like "sorry" as a predicate adjective the subject has to be connected to it by copula (linking verb). You can't substitute the adjective for the verb. Therefore you would be correct if the sentence said "Mr. Fetlocks is sorry, but..."

Look on the bright side. You've learned some Physics, History and English grammar today.

I speak good England too, me. Innit.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.