daztrueblue91
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 4 Jun 2009
- Messages
- 4,099
I think it's a little bit harsh to say we were reactive in a bad sense. Just because I do not believe it is by choice in any way. We signed one of our primary targets in Gvardiol for a good fee. Our other primary target in Belligham chose to bring his talents (which he has plenty of ffs) to Madrid. Can't really blame the lad. Thus, moving on to negotiations with next primary target in Rice. I assume he preferred the surefire role at Arsenal and the ability to stay in London. Fine. Then we moved to Paqueta which didn't work for obvious reasons. And now Nunes has popped up. Quite late yes but we're talking deals valued at hundreds of millions of dollars. I'm sure we just want to do our due-diligence and not be reactive by just putting pen to paper on the next bloke available.
We gave some of our club legends time to make the right decision and get the moves they want, meanwhile we were planning our moves no doubt. Yes this was a bit frustrating but the lads earned the time in my opinion. Once Mahrez confirmed his departure we brought in Doku shortly after, same with Gundo and Kovacic. This stuff surely goes a long way in the eyes of players looking to sign with City down the road.
We also managed to secure the signature of Bernardo Silva, which may not have happened if we signed a big midfielder. He may have wanted the security of more minutes. Also giving us reason to play it slow. No way to know this; maybe City had a better idea that Bernardo would stay than the public (shocker).
Once the window closes in the next couple days I think we'll look back and think it was a success. Assuming one more lad comes in. We moved out aging players for decent fees and brought in some real talent. If you told me 6 months ago that we wouldn't sign Jude then I'd have said no way will this be a good window, but I think we've been smart with the hand we were dealt.
I completely agree and I think it’s needs pointing out that our club rarely get it wrong in the transfer window. I’d argue we’re one of, if not the, best run clubs in the world.
The club has set such high standards that a good window like this feels somewhat off.
As others have pointed out, the Gvardiol and Kovacic deals typify the approach City take in the market. They were identified early and brought to the club for decent fees.
The midfielder search just seems at odds with this approach. We’ve gone from Bellingham to Rice to Paqueta, three completely different types of player all for fees at the top end of what we usually pay.
I remember when we wanted a Vinny replacement we looked a Koulibaly. It didn’t materialise so we got Dias, another strong commanding CB. We wanted a DM who could control the game in Jorginho, he didn’t come so we got Rodri. This current midfielder search seems a bit more erratic than that.
I completely disagree about Bernardo though. The guy is world class and would start for us no matter who we brought in. Pep loves him as well.