Most Overrated Player to Play for City

[Blue Til Death]

Hart and Sterling

mick Channon

You are posting in the wrong thread mate, you have just named 2 of the best players we've ever had ....!!!!
Some people have seriously short memories... Mick Channon was ok too ....

 

[Irish Blue82]

Present - Ederson, think he's an average goalkeeper that wouldn't play for us if he wasn't so good with his left peg. Still yet to have a game where he looks unbeatable

I tend to agree. Ederson with the ball at his feet is brilliant but when it comes to just keeping the ball out of the net we've had better. Been a City fan since the early 90s and in my opinion from the keepers I've seen Coton,Given, Hart and David James were better shot stoppers. That being said none of them would get in Peps team because of their distribution!

 

[decmancity]

I tend to agree. Ederson with the ball at his feet is brilliant but when it comes to just keeping the ball out of the net we've had better. Been a City fan since the early 90s and in my opinion from the keepers I've seen Coton,Given, Hart and David James were better shot stoppers. That being said none of them would get in Peps team because of their distribution!

Behave. Given and Hart good shot stoppers on their day but Ederson is better than both and the rest of those mentioned. He rarely has to make any saves which is perhaps why you don't have many memories of them and there has been games he has had the dreaded Bravo stat of; 1 shot on target 1 conceded but that doesn't tell the story of the goal.

 

[Irish Blue82]

Dont think he was a better shot stopper than Tony Coton,he was the best I've seen at city! In the early to mid 90s only Schmiechel was better than him in the 1st division/premier league! Not a lot between Ederson and the others I mentioned. Just my opinion!

 

[oakiecokie]

I honestly believe there is some serious wumming going on in this thread.

 

[2bluejacko]

Nicolas Anelka Amd Darius Vassell both needed about 30 opportunities per goal and both were awful at one on ones. Of the current crop Mahrez cos he’s a greedy twat and the most selfish player I’ve seen at City since Trevor Francis

Wow, I have read it all now...
Anelka awful at one on ones
He was a class act and I would love to see what he could do with the service he would get now

 

[Irish Blue82]

Wow, I have read it all now...
Anelka awful at one on ones
He was a class act and I would love to see what he could do with the service he would get now

Anelka would score a ton of goals if he were playing in the current side!

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

Kinkladze and I'm prepared to offer out any cünt who disagrees with me.

You want some?

 

[ctid1894]

Anelka would score a ton of goals if he were playing in the current side!

He wouldn't even get on the bench, due to his relaxed nature.

 

[peoffrey]

Anelka’s had more clubs than Tiger Woods for a reason.