You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Nasri Appeal (merged).
- Thread starter mancity1
- Start date
oakiecokie
Well-Known Member
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Think back to "aggresive walking" by Kevin Horlock. ;)
Jumanji said:It is unfathomable to me how you do not see Nasri's headbutt/swipe as violent. Yes, unfathomable.Caveman said:Violent conduct is violent conduct and I know what violent conduct is. What Nasri did is not violence in real life, other sports or anything.
Is it the worst thing he could have done? Far from it...But to deny it as an act of violence and aggression, when it clearly is, I can't understand.
Think back to "aggresive walking" by Kevin Horlock. ;)
bluecityboy
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 17 Mar 2011
- Messages
- 959
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Can we appeal against the decision of Van Persie not getting a red? If only we lived in a fair world
Can we appeal against the decision of Van Persie not getting a red? If only we lived in a fair world
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Is an aggressive flick of the head violent conduct if there's no contact?
Compare it to the tackle. I think we should appeal, but worth looking at previous incidents that have been before the FA panel. Must have been one
Is an aggressive flick of the head violent conduct if there's no contact?
Compare it to the tackle. I think we should appeal, but worth looking at previous incidents that have been before the FA panel. Must have been one
D
D
Deleted member 52846
Guest
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
I posted the laws myself a few laws back.<br /><br />-- Sun Dec 30, 2012 12:57 am --<br /><br />St Helens Blue (Exiled) said:Huge fail..read the laws of football under red card offences.its over.let it go mateCaveman said:This thread is about Nasri's incident so why would I talk about other things in here?St Helens Blue (Exiled) said:Yes i would give it up blue.You are sounding like a silly child who is stamping his feet...we won..just enjoy and get ready for the cloggers on tuesday
Violent conduct is violent conduct and I know what violent conduct is. What Nasri did is not violence in real life, other sports or anything.
Dunno. I just don't see it. Silly play, but not violence.Jumanji said:It is unfathomable to me how you do not see Nasri's headbutt/swipe as violent. Yes, unfathomable.Caveman said:Violent conduct is violent conduct and I know what violent conduct is. What Nasri did is not violence in real life, other sports or anything.
Is it the worst thing he could have done? Far from it...But to deny it as an act of violence and aggression, when it clearly is, I can't understand.
dw7
Well-Known Member
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Can we appeal to make it 10 games
Can we appeal to make it 10 games
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
The rule book has always been a bit different for us. Who can forget the second yellow/red card for aggressive walking (Horlock)!
Marvin said:How can there be violence if Nasri doesn't make contact with Bassong? Is a gesture violent
The rule book has always been a bit different for us. Who can forget the second yellow/red card for aggressive walking (Horlock)!
FantasyIreland
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Oct 2008
- Messages
- 64,697
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Spot on,it's bollox but by the letter.......red card all day.
Caught up in emotion but a silly boy.
Dobsy said:It is a definite red under the rules. It was violent conduct.
The conspiracy theorists really undermine themselves when they bleat about decisions like this that are clearly right.
Spot on,it's bollox but by the letter.......red card all day.
Caught up in emotion but a silly boy.