Gaylord du Bois
Well-Known Member
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Ooh undermine, get you smarty pants.Dobsy said:
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Nasri Appeal (merged).
- Thread starter mancity1
- Start date
Aguero_Element
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 10 Jan 2012
- Messages
- 5,409
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Ur a silly boy
Ur a silly boy
Bluemoonbaldboy
Well-Known Member
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Why appeal a correct decision. The only error was Bassong should have gone as well when Nasri pulled away from it Bassong stuck his head back in Nasris face
Why appeal a correct decision. The only error was Bassong should have gone as well when Nasri pulled away from it Bassong stuck his head back in Nasris face
sir baconface
Well-Known Member
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Harsh but technically correct so no use appealing.
Nasri appeared to nut him on the shoulder. What's the point of that ffs?
Harsh but technically correct so no use appealing.
Nasri appeared to nut him on the shoulder. What's the point of that ffs?
coulsonblue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 1 Mar 2007
- Messages
- 1,519
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
stop with this intent nonsense. You should not be done unless you actually do something.
You can't be charged with murder/gbh/criminal damage (whatever) without actually commiting the offence regardless of intent. same should apply in football.
stop with this intent nonsense. You should not be done unless you actually do something.
You can't be charged with murder/gbh/criminal damage (whatever) without actually commiting the offence regardless of intent. same should apply in football.
FantasyIreland
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Oct 2008
- Messages
- 64,697
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Manchester City will appeal against the red card given to Samir Nasri just before half-time at Norwich yesterday, after which they still managed to win 4-3 and stay seven points behind Manchester United at the top of the Premier League.
After Nasri reacted to a fierce challenge by Sébastien Bassong by going head to head with the Norwich defender, Mancini felt that either both players or neither should have been dismissed. "Samir said he touched him, but the other player did the same," City's manager said. "I'm disappointed with Samir, he made a mistake and he will pay a fine. But I want the rules to be the same for everyone. I always hate this two rules for different players. I can't accept this."
Unless the appeal is successful, Nasri will miss games against Stoke City on Tuesday and his former club Arsenal, plus the FA Cup tie at home to Watford. Mancini is also facing a possible Football Association charge after joking that Kevin Friend, the referee of his side's Boxing Day defeat at Sunderland, had eaten too much at Christmas. The Italian resisted any similar quips yesterday.
Chris Hughton, the Norwich manager, felt the red card was "harsh". He said: "There was certainly a coming together of heads and some movement from Nasri. But was it harsh? Probably yes."
United's 2-0 win at home to West Bromwich Albion, secured thanks to Gareth McAuley's own goal and Robin van Persie's late strike, meant Sir Alex Ferguson's side maintained their lead at the top.
"At the moment United are better than us because they are top, but it's not important to look at the table now," added Mancini.
Behind the Manchester clubs, Tottenham Hotspur moved up to third with a 2-1 win at Sunderland, but Andre Villas-Boas was unhappy with the decision to book Gareth Bale for diving. "Today was a big mistake," the Spurs manager said.
Manchester City will appeal against the red card given to Samir Nasri just before half-time at Norwich yesterday, after which they still managed to win 4-3 and stay seven points behind Manchester United at the top of the Premier League.
After Nasri reacted to a fierce challenge by Sébastien Bassong by going head to head with the Norwich defender, Mancini felt that either both players or neither should have been dismissed. "Samir said he touched him, but the other player did the same," City's manager said. "I'm disappointed with Samir, he made a mistake and he will pay a fine. But I want the rules to be the same for everyone. I always hate this two rules for different players. I can't accept this."
Unless the appeal is successful, Nasri will miss games against Stoke City on Tuesday and his former club Arsenal, plus the FA Cup tie at home to Watford. Mancini is also facing a possible Football Association charge after joking that Kevin Friend, the referee of his side's Boxing Day defeat at Sunderland, had eaten too much at Christmas. The Italian resisted any similar quips yesterday.
Chris Hughton, the Norwich manager, felt the red card was "harsh". He said: "There was certainly a coming together of heads and some movement from Nasri. But was it harsh? Probably yes."
United's 2-0 win at home to West Bromwich Albion, secured thanks to Gareth McAuley's own goal and Robin van Persie's late strike, meant Sir Alex Ferguson's side maintained their lead at the top.
"At the moment United are better than us because they are top, but it's not important to look at the table now," added Mancini.
Behind the Manchester clubs, Tottenham Hotspur moved up to third with a 2-1 win at Sunderland, but Andre Villas-Boas was unhappy with the decision to book Gareth Bale for diving. "Today was a big mistake," the Spurs manager said.
D
D
Deleted member 52846
Guest
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
For me it falls under this part of the law:
For me it isn't an action of violence, it's an act of aggressive attitude or inflammatory behaviour. His actions could not have hurt his opponent, but could have sparked further aggressive behaviour or even violence. Violence did not occur.
For me it falls under this part of the law:
Which is part of the "Cautionable Offences" law.Commits an act which, in the opinion of the referee, shows a lack of respect for the game (e.g., aggressive attitude, inflammatory behavior, or taunting)
For me it isn't an action of violence, it's an act of aggressive attitude or inflammatory behaviour. His actions could not have hurt his opponent, but could have sparked further aggressive behaviour or even violence. Violence did not occur.
D
D
Deleted member 52846
Guest
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Good.FantasyIreland said:Manchester City will appeal against the red card given to Samir Nasri just before half-time at Norwich yesterday, after which they still managed to win 4-3 and stay seven points behind Manchester United at the top of the Premier League.
After Nasri reacted to a fierce challenge by Sébastien Bassong by going head to head with the Norwich defender, Mancini felt that either both players or neither should have been dismissed. "Samir said he touched him, but the other player did the same," City's manager said. "I'm disappointed with Samir, he made a mistake and he will pay a fine. But I want the rules to be the same for everyone. I always hate this two rules for different players. I can't accept this."
Unless the appeal is successful, Nasri will miss games against Stoke City on Tuesday and his former club Arsenal, plus the FA Cup tie at home to Watford. Mancini is also facing a possible Football Association charge after joking that Kevin Friend, the referee of his side's Boxing Day defeat at Sunderland, had eaten too much at Christmas. The Italian resisted any similar quips yesterday.
Chris Hughton, the Norwich manager, felt the red card was "harsh". He said: "There was certainly a coming together of heads and some movement from Nasri. But was it harsh? Probably yes."
United's 2-0 win at home to West Bromwich Albion, secured thanks to Gareth McAuley's own goal and Robin van Persie's late strike, meant Sir Alex Ferguson's side maintained their lead at the top.
"At the moment United are better than us because they are top, but it's not important to look at the table now," added Mancini.
Behind the Manchester clubs, Tottenham Hotspur moved up to third with a 2-1 win at Sunderland, but Andre Villas-Boas was unhappy with the decision to book Gareth Bale for diving. "Today was a big mistake," the Spurs manager said.