You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Nasri Appeal (merged).
- Thread starter mancity1
- Start date
thedogsbollocks
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 Dec 2012
- Messages
- 244
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
I don't have a problem with the red.He stuck his head in his face, it was dumb and he was sent off for it.
My problem is,how Red nose can gob it at officials,haranguing and abusing etc ( unpunished).............RVP did a similar to Nasri much worse last week (unpunished)...............Rooney abuses official every fcuking match ( unpunished)
thats my gripe,the double standards,and embarrassingly biased officiating week on week.
I don't have a problem with the red.He stuck his head in his face, it was dumb and he was sent off for it.
My problem is,how Red nose can gob it at officials,haranguing and abusing etc ( unpunished).............RVP did a similar to Nasri much worse last week (unpunished)...............Rooney abuses official every fcuking match ( unpunished)
thats my gripe,the double standards,and embarrassingly biased officiating week on week.
robbie brewer
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 27 May 2009
- Messages
- 339
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
There is absolutely no point in appealing for the following reason:
Rule 1. The referee is always right.
Rule 2. When the referee is wrong Rule 1 applies.
Anyone who thinks Bassong should get his his yellow card upgraded to a red is missing the point. He was yellow carded at the time and therefore the incident was dealt with and cannot be subject of retrospective action.
Finally Nasri's actions amount to violent conduct the fact there is minimal contact is irrelevant the fact there is contact makes it an act of violence and therefore is violent conduct.
There is absolutely no point in appealing for the following reason:
Rule 1. The referee is always right.
Rule 2. When the referee is wrong Rule 1 applies.
Anyone who thinks Bassong should get his his yellow card upgraded to a red is missing the point. He was yellow carded at the time and therefore the incident was dealt with and cannot be subject of retrospective action.
Finally Nasri's actions amount to violent conduct the fact there is minimal contact is irrelevant the fact there is contact makes it an act of violence and therefore is violent conduct.
Helmet Cole
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 Jul 2007
- Messages
- 8,054
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
7-8 times out of ten Sami would have got away with it, moving his head like that means the ref had an excuse and an appeal would be useless. IMHO we would be better off pursuing the back-pass/ push-over, and the fact that the ref had a stinker in general - the Nasri incident is actually not one of his worse decisions today which is why it wasn't 0-7.
7-8 times out of ten Sami would have got away with it, moving his head like that means the ref had an excuse and an appeal would be useless. IMHO we would be better off pursuing the back-pass/ push-over, and the fact that the ref had a stinker in general - the Nasri incident is actually not one of his worse decisions today which is why it wasn't 0-7.
Helmet Cole
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 Jul 2007
- Messages
- 8,054
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
Not at all Pam, I'm assuming todays performance has ensured the ref is on Fergiescums list of FA approved refs for home games at the swamp.Pam said:Some of you are forgetting how bent the FA are.
cleavers
Moderator
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
He should also have had a yellow minutes earlier for a foul, but got away with it.
He was yellow carded for the foul, yet he put his head into Nasri, much as Nasri did to him, yet he escaped further punishment.robbie brewer said:Anyone who thinks Bassong should get his his yellow card upgraded to a red is missing the point. He was yellow carded at the time and therefore the incident was dealt with and cannot be subject of retrospective action.
He should also have had a yellow minutes earlier for a foul, but got away with it.
Helmet Cole
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 Jul 2007
- Messages
- 8,054
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
TBH I'm not a fan of the Monday morning retrospective reffing. We got shafted by it last year and I just don't like it. My main issue is that (like last year) it seems some games/incidents are looked at more than others at FA headquarters on a Monday. At least a bent/shit ref on a Saturday has to do it in front of 30-60'000 witnesses and MOTD.
cleavers said:He was yellow carded for the foul, yet he put his head into Nasri, much as Nasri did to him, yet he escaped further punishment.robbie brewer said:Anyone who thinks Bassong should get his his yellow card upgraded to a red is missing the point. He was yellow carded at the time and therefore the incident was dealt with and cannot be subject of retrospective action.
He should also have had a yellow minutes earlier for a foul, but got away with it.
TBH I'm not a fan of the Monday morning retrospective reffing. We got shafted by it last year and I just don't like it. My main issue is that (like last year) it seems some games/incidents are looked at more than others at FA headquarters on a Monday. At least a bent/shit ref on a Saturday has to do it in front of 30-60'000 witnesses and MOTD.
robbie brewer
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 27 May 2009
- Messages
- 339
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
I know what you mean but the FA will still see it as dealt with, I wasn't saying it was right just what the FA would say. Nasri was also sent off on the basis of what the linesman saw not what the ref saw so the ref didn't deem it a red card he probably thought the yellow for the foul was sufficient for the whole incident but once the linesman says Nasri butted Bassong he has no choice but to send him off. If the FA ask him to look at it again I doubt he will change his mind.
cleavers said:He was yellow carded for the foul, yet he put his head into Nasri, much as Nasri did to him, yet he escaped further punishment.robbie brewer said:Anyone who thinks Bassong should get his his yellow card upgraded to a red is missing the point. He was yellow carded at the time and therefore the incident was dealt with and cannot be subject of retrospective action.
He should also have had a yellow minutes earlier for a foul, but got away with it.
I know what you mean but the FA will still see it as dealt with, I wasn't saying it was right just what the FA would say. Nasri was also sent off on the basis of what the linesman saw not what the ref saw so the ref didn't deem it a red card he probably thought the yellow for the foul was sufficient for the whole incident but once the linesman says Nasri butted Bassong he has no choice but to send him off. If the FA ask him to look at it again I doubt he will change his mind.
Re: Appeal or not? SN.
I think you may find that you can be
coulsonblue said:stop with this intent nonsense. You should not be done unless you actually do something.
You can't be charged with murder/gbh/criminal damage (whatever) without actually commiting the offence regardless of intent. same should apply in football.
I think you may find that you can be