Newcastle United (A) | Post Match thread

It is patently ridiculous that a knee high professional foul on a player sprinting by you is NOT a red card. It’s one thing to pull his shirt, trip/ankle tap him, but when he’s so far past you you have to take him out knee height…which was OBVIOUS from the VAR WE COULD SEE ON TV…is ridiculous.

New ref bottled it!

That said, too many players didn’t deserve to be on a winning team today. Back four, which is our supposed “best line up,” looked weak, disorganized and deathly afraid of runners!

Called it before the game: St Maximin on the left & cutting in, Wilson or another cutting in on the diagonal, and the chance of a worldie! GOT ALL THREE!!

If I can see it from prior NUFC highlights, WTF?!

On the City side of the ledger, it is clear that if you put pressure on Rodri, Cancelo & Walker as a midfield 3, then you’re going to get some change out of at least 2 of 3 all game! It takes balls, because we are then playing with 5 attackers, but with willing runners, NUFC showed it’s doable…esp when Walker & Cancelo are having stinkers.

Have to say, Haaland had a few chances to win the game, but to be fair, only one was a clear cut “should have scored” chance. In addition, the service we give him beggars belief!

Howe has ALWAYS set up his teams to try to exploit our CLEAR weaknesses, and he’s finally got the players to do it…and did in the first half. Once we got going, we pinned them back a bit, but (apart from the Pass of the Season), we were very poor in and around the box!

Second in the League after that performance? I’ll take it, but…

The Toon had more tactical fouls than we ever did in our Tactical Fouling Pomp. If it had been City, they would be screaming for reds.
 
Is Ake right now our best defender genuine question. He's been brilliant last season and started this season brilliantly
I`ve been beating the drum ref this lad from the moment he signed and he was given a bit of a rough ride by some of our supporters mainly due to the fact that he didn`t come from a "fashionable club".
The lad has been immense for us for months now.
 
Don’t people see the problem with Rodri in games like these? When we have the ball with 70-80% possesion in games, he’s loving life. With time on his side and no pressure from the opposition, he could pick out anyone to pass to. But in games like these when they are closing him down, his weaknesses are shown very clearly. His defensive contributions are a problem. That’s always been my view.
Not saying this is on him, but Newcastle just sliced through our midfield today.
No Newcastle sliced through Kyle's side today.
 
What have we ever done to Hinchcliffe? Is the big chinned tw*t just bitter because he played for us pre takeover? (Not that it is an issue, should be honoured to wear our badge no matter the era)

He's just a bitter **** who doesn't have a decent word to say about City .

He's the one with the problem so fuck him.
 
Newcastle got a deserved draw. From minute one they played like the team with something to prove, & we just continued at our comfortable early season pace.

It was evident very early that Newcastle were targeting Rodri by closing him down & giving him zero time on the ball. They were also targeting the space Walker leaves in behind when he plays centrally.

With St Maximin driving into that space, Joelinton kept bombing down the right to give St Maximin the choice of playing the ball back out to the wing, or driving inside, & we just never dealt with this tactic & it kept causing us a whole heap of problems.

They eventually scored by closing down a dawdling Rodri & playing the ball into our vacated right back space, & this is how their first two goals originated.

In my opinion Rodri was to blame for their first two goals, as he keeps having lapses of thinking he's got all the time in the world when on the ball.

TWICE he waited for passes to come to him instead of advancing to meet the ball & twice a Newcastle player nipped in & took the ball off his toes which put us under heavy pressure.

At times we looked in disarray defensively, & just like Chelsea with Leeds earlier, we struggled to pick up the pace & match the opposition's intensity.

You could see this match meant everything to the Geordies, but we approached it like a standard PL game & it wasn't until after Trippier's free kick midway through the second half that we started to match their intensity & it was only then our extra quality told.

We scored the two goals to equalise & it became evident Newcastle were gonna be happy with a draw & were playing us on the counter & taking few defensive risks, unlike in the first.

When Rodri FINALLY upped his intensity, we began to tick & then it clicked & Newcastle were firmly of the mind of what we have, we hold.

I've no issues with the straight red being rescinded, as I was surprised when the card was shown. A yellow was the correct call.

I had a feeling of foreboding about this match, ESPECIALLY as the media kept playing up the "Almiron" comment from Grealish at the end of the season. I'd suggest that was the reason he wasn't in the squad & not because of a knock he received last weekend.

I reckon the Grealish comment & Newcastle wanting to test where they really are as a football team were the primary reasons why they played like this was a title or relegation decider.

Haaland played his best game for us today, by dropping deeper to add to our midfield numbers which created spaces where their central defence didn't know whether to advance to track him, or to drop off & leave the defensive midfielders to drop deep to cover him. Either way, he kept creating spaces for us to play in & was more involved in the game.

Overall it was our failure to raise our tempo to match Newcastle's until it was too late & Rodri's fuckin dawdling on the ball which ultimately cost us today. On reflection we got what we deserved, but at least we didn't drop all three points which was a distinct possibility based on our first half display.

Hopefully this is the wakeup call we needed to know we have to fight fire with fire for the whole game, or in the PL there's a good chance it will cost us. Gutted to lose two valuable points, but relieved to get one. :-|

Roll on Wednesday...
 
Disappointing but I take it as a point gained and not two points dropped. Could be a crucial point at the end of the season. We were defensively terrible as soon as Ake went off. Walker should have been took off after 20 mins you could tell he was struggling. Foden not squaring it for the second consecutive week is frustrating - think he is trying too hard myself. Erling was superb today, just surprised we never got to see Alvarez - think he could have been effective in that last 15.

Anyways onwards and upwards. Palace next, going to be tough. Zaha and Eze will fancy this after seeing our defence today. Need to be on it from the get go and I'd like to see Kalvin playing next to Rodri to help give the defence a bit more shield especially with Kyle and Joao basically in midfield. Any open spaces and Palace will punish us like they did last year. Probably have to sacrifice Gundo to get Kalv in which is unfortunate (between him and Kev) but he can always come back in for Forest who don't offer any threat on the break.
 
Eddie Howe got his tactics spot on by exploiting the wide areas, particularly on the left. Pep announced his full backs into midfield ploy , repeating it from the west Ham game and Newcastle had the players to counter it.
Ok walker was playing to order, but ive always thought his atitude is akin to a complete dick. Going forward he offers us very little so why not play him to his strength as a conventional fullback ?
Also Ive always thought that a "transition" deliberate foul should carry more than just a yellow card. How about card plus sin bin ?
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.