I can't believe this is even worthy of discussion.
vinnie is our captain. He leads with the respect of the other players, with calm, with grace, with diplomacy, with eloquence, with leadership skills. He is unequalled and probably the best captain City have had for many years, if not all time. You will be hard pushed to name a team captain better skilled than Vinnie in any team team around the globe. We are honoured to call him ours.
Pab has blue blood in his veins. He has fought for us, bled for us and been a stalwart in defence feared by many. He's a great workhorse, dedicated and committed to City. But it doesn't make him a better captain than Vinnie.
Now put your beers down and go to bed. Tomorrow you will see the error of your ways.