Porto fan here.
Just signed up to the forum. Long time Premier League watcher. Occasional lurker on this forum. Especially since the Garcia signing from Benfica. I thought about registering then, alerting you to what you were buying, in the end I didn't, but I do now, because I am very curious to see what kind of level will Fernando reach in a more challenging league and whether he nails down a place in the team.
Fernando is a player that will be dearly missed at Porto. He was the heart or the lungs of the team. Always the unsung hero. Criminally underrated by everyone, including the board, who never really valued him accordingly to his value to the team. The market always seemed to overlook him as well. He arrived in 2007 from some third division team from Brazil. He was loaned out and quickly managed to be a starter in the top division in Portugal. Next season, Porto lost their very reliable holding midfielder to Atletico Madrid(Paulo Assunção) and Fernando, as a 21 year old filled the hole right away and we never looked back. Ever since then he gradually became a silent beast in the team. Looking back, having played with Falcao, Moutinho, James, Hulk, Lisandro Lopez, Guarin, Lucho and several great players, he has always been my favourite player and really... the most important player. His stamina, his aggressiveness, his selfless work, the way he runs around all game and lasts the full season, arriving at the second half of the season still being dominant was key for Porto. Not only locally, but also internationally, winning the Europa League, almost knocking out United in the quarters of the UCL(in the year they won it).
The one thing that always intrigued me about Fernando was that just as he was so prominent for Porto and with so many players being sold for huge sums, no one seemed to really value and appreciate him. At best, he was linked with the likes of Inter Milan. As said above, he never got a good new contract, so he was always at the start of the season a bit unsettled, feeling unappreciated, not valued, not in contention for the national team. It was frustrating to witness. Once the season started, he was back to his usual self of swallow everything that reached the defensive midfield, contributing to two league titles with no defeats 10/11 and 12/13.
This is where the Javi Garcia part also contributed to my amazement. Manchester City, current Premier League Champions were buying a defensive midfielder in the Portuguese League... and they were shelling out 20M Euros for... Javi Garcia!? Seriously... it was shocking. He was slow, didn't have a great range of acting and got away with a lot because he played for Benfica. I know I am partial, but Javi Garcia and David Luiz are two of the more overrated players that I saw recently in Portugal. That's when I started reading this forum more, just to see what kind of things would be said about him and follow his development in the Premier League. I know that he did prove what I anticipated, he was way overpriced, too slow for the league and looked out of place. He ended up filling a role either as centre back or midfield last season and seems like a reliable character, so in the end, not totally disastrous, but still, very short of the required quality at this level.
Fernando always played at Porto in the 433, sitting behind two complete midfielders. With most of the top teams in Europe playing with only two midfielders in the 4231, Fernando was always looked as someone who lacked the technical ability to play in a two man midfield, pass the ball around, charge forward, being an all around player. He improved a lot over the years. He is much better on the ball now. You could see that he really tried to stand out more and more with the ball(the guy clearly was trying to show that he is more than a destroyer), he is far from Fernandinho's level driving forward, not only technically, but mainly... just lacking the experience of playing further up the pitch, being more comfortable and being able to execute and decide better. That requires experience that he never really had at Porto since he had two other central midfielders ahead of him.
I anticipate him being a regular option for the bigger games, where Pellegrini will likely field a three headed monster in midfield. Some away games as well. It will be interesting to see if he manages to establish himself quickly doing what he does best, which is... chasing everyone and making great tackles. He is a tireless player, very athletic, so the style of play in the Premier League shouldn't be a problem. I am curious to see whether he manages to push Fernandinho for a regular place in the team or maybe Yaya turns into more of a regular attacking midfielder and Silva drifts to the right. One thing is for sure, he will be a bargain. Comparing him with William Carvalho, linked with United, he is much better without the ball, more physical, faster and tenacious. Carvalho is just a smart player, with good feet and good passing range, but he is more likely to be exposed by the pace of the league than Fernando and at Sporting's current asking price, Carvalho is a bit like Mangala, great potential, but great risk.
It took a long time and 27 is an unusual age for a player to leave a league like the Portuguese for the Premier League. In the end, he will have the chance to play for one of the top teams and be challenging for titles and and be tested every week. The road might not have been straightforward, but he managed to find a good place. I'll be closely monitoring his progress. Hopefully he doesn't disappoint.