Palestine Action

Manc Born & Bred said:
You are so funny. Explain why anti semitic crimes have surged worldwide since October 2023 if Jews aren’t being targeted. In fact no need to answer as you like the rest of the anti semites will be on ignore. Oh and before you call someone mentally regarded you might want to have a think about your choice of words.
Click to expand...
*Retarded.
 
Bluemoon_420 said:
I think it’s important not to sanitise what’s actually happening on the ground through the “Hasbara” lens. These aren’t just “tragic accidents” or “things going wrong.” A very large number of the victims aren’t Hamas fighters (70% +) but ordinary civilians and disproportionately children. In Gaza, over half the population are children, and they have made up a horrifying percentage of the casualties.

There’s hundreds of credible reports from human rights groups and eyewitnesses (doctors etc.) that have documented cases where civilians, including women and children, were deliberately shot by snipers. That’s not the same as a bomb hitting the wrong building – that’s targeted killing of innocents. When a child is shot in the head by a sniper while searching for food or water, calling it “collateral damage” is deeply misleading.

You’re right that Israel often issues warnings before bombing, but that doesn’t negate responsibility when whole families are wiped out in their homes, or when areas civilians are told to flee to are bombed as well. And unlike other conflicts, civilians in Gaza don’t have the ability to leave to safety, borders are sealed, movement is blocked, and people are trapped under siege - this had been the case prior to Oct 7th but maybe not as extreme.

As for your last point absolutely, Jewish people here should not be held responsible for the actions of the Israeli government, just as Muslims worldwide should not be blamed for the crimes of extremist groups. But acknowledging and condemning antisemitism doesn’t require us to look away from what’s happening to innocent people in Gaza. Both truths can and should coexist: it’s wrong to target Jews in the UK, and it’s also wrong and far more horrific that thousands of civilians many of them children are being killed, some deliberately by sniper fire and other nefarious methods.
Click to expand...
Let's ban all religions.
Fancy killing each other in the name of invisible entities who no one can prove existed for ideals which no one can live up to?!
Utterly insane.
 
Grassland Blue said:
I'd throw the book at the protesters,






the quran of course!
Click to expand...

If that’s your punchline, the joke’s on you. Mocking someone’s holy book isn’t justice, it’s just plain bigotry.

Congrats on exposing yourself as the ignoramus you are yet again. Still haven’t answered the reply to your nonsense in the Middle East thread? Or are you too busy waving flags and abusing brown people?
 
Last edited:
BerkshireBlue said:
Of course they have a right to a state. Its people we are talking about. Such a stupid question to ask. Why are you giving conditions fir the Palestinian state to exist. I presume you agree for all Jews to be removed from the West Bank and Gaza as well for this state to exist. Also the Jews need to stop bombing all areas and return the Palestinian hostages they are holding and vice versa. To be honest you are making this a Jews vs Palestinian thing when its actually Israelians vs Palestinians. Bringing religion into it is just dumb
Click to expand...
Israelites, or Israelis.....
 
Israel has just crossed another line. One that's going to have huge repercussions for them. Starmer cannot stand by anymore, it's time for action
 
BerkshireBlue said:
Israel has just crossed another line. One that's going to have huge repercussions for them. Starmer cannot stand by anymore, it's time for action
Click to expand...
Sadly they haven't crossed any line.
The Israeli Prime Minister will still be welcomed and Palestinian Action will still be a terrorist organisation.
Starmer is too busy fighting Farage over immigration to see that this is a stupid over reaction.
If he cannot understand why pensioners are willing to be arrested he is in the wrong job.

A sensible PM would find a way to graciously back down.
 
Grassland Blue said:
Let's ban all religions.
Fancy killing each other in the name of invisible entities who no one can prove existed for ideals which no one can live up to?!
Utterly insane.
Click to expand...
Can't remember where I saw it but it's a great point....there have been around 3,000 gods to choose from. People believe in one less god than those of us who think there are none. Everyone doesn't believe in 2,999 of them. Batshit.
 
Robanompivenov said:
Can't remember where I saw it but it's a great point....there have been around 3,000 gods to choose from. People believe in one less god than those of us who think there are none. Everyone doesn't believe in 2,999 of them. Batshit.
Click to expand...
Except most people dying in Palestine don't really give a fuck which god is killing them.
The current government totally overreacted. Were they pushed in a certain direction by an orange shit gibbon and a out of control state ?
 
Last edited:
Blue Mist said:
Except most people dying in Palestine don't really give a fuck which god is killing them.
The current government totally overreacted. We're they pushed in a certain direction by an orange shit gibbon and a out of control state ?
Click to expand...
It was a general point about religion mate. My comment to your post in the other thread should summise how I feel about the genocide occurring in Gaza.
 
To blame religion is reductive.

Most of the Israeli cabinet are secular nationalists with fringe religious extremists in as a coalition.

Israel has a nationalism problem and a racism problem.

Palestine is home to Christians and Muslims. Both are killed indiscriminately by the secular IDF.
 
Nickyweaver01 said:
To blame religion is reductive.

Most of the Israeli cabinet are secular nationalists with fringe religious extremists in as a coalition.

Israel has a nationalism problem and a racism problem.

Palestine is home to Christians and Muslims. Both are killed indiscriminately by the secular IDF.
Click to expand...
Do people come from America to settle in the West Bank because they're nationalists? About a nation that they don't come from and didn't grow up in? Or is religion the prime motivator? The might be nationalists and racists too, but let's not pretend religion is just some fringe element.
 
Bluemoon_420 said:
If that’s your punchline, the joke’s on you. Mocking someone’s holy book isn’t justice, it’s just plain bigotry.

Congrats on exposing yourself as the ignoramus you are yet again. Still haven’t answered the reply to your nonsense in the Middle East thread? Or are you too busy waving flags and abusing brown people?
Click to expand...
And I suppose that you want the Jews wiped from the face of the earth...?..
 
Grassland Blue said:
And I suppose that you want the Jews wiped from the face of the earth...?..
Click to expand...
Look at it a different way.
In 20 years time, if only one out of 3 Palestinian children, orphaned, starved, removed to a foreign country decide to fight back and become freedom fighters/terrorists, will Israel be safe ?

What the Israeli government are doing does not have a long term peaceful solution. The children or grandchildren of Netanyahu and his murderous co-horts will not be safe.

They cannot kill every Palestinian no matter how hard they try
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top