I get what you are saying and it's really semantics from what my opinion is.
I think the whole world knows Pep lives and breathes football. He thinks about everything and studies every detail. I don't think there's a team out there he wouldn't be preparing for in the same way. But equally, we don't know what results could have been had we played different formations/styles so it's hard to know just how wrong he has got things. As he always says, when it comes off he's a genius and when it doesn't he's criticised. That's his job.
You look at the Liverpool game and there were definitely issues, but we should have had a pen. And Sane wrongly had a goal disallowed in the first half that could have made it 2-0. With the penalty given and scored (pushing it!) we'd have been going through. The Spurs games he didn't do anything wrong. We wanted to push for a goal in the first leg, De Bruyne was held back, but we were in an almighty battle for the league. And Llorente's goal would have been disallowed for handball this year.
He also made changes for our game in Madrid which we won, but the subsequent changes he made for Lyon were obviously criticised. The lineup was shocking and most of us felt we were out at that point. But we got back into the game and created plenty of chances to score and win it. Individual errors/misses were more to blame than Pep's formation and tactics.
But I think you are right overall. He seems more confident in the side now. He has established a real balance to our team and is trusting on the usual tactics, formation and players to get the job done in Europe. There was a definite reluctance to overcommit in the first half. Whether that was Pep or the players I'm not sure, but I'd guess it was Pep. We reverted to our usual game in the second and were top class.
I've no idea if it was by instruction, or if it was the players, but after the first ten minutes PSG had the momentum & took the lead.
As a sign of how far we've come, normally I'd be looking to end it all, but last night I knew they had as much to worry about as we did, & all I was hoping for was to get in at 1-0, or for us to sneak an equaliser. We just needed to press the reset button, remember what we were capable of & give PSG something to think about.
As I said earlier, as soon as the second half kicked off, Silva closed in on Mahrez to offer a passing option, & Walker went racing past on the overlap leaving Bakker looking left & right & not really knowing who to pick up.
At this point it's like we remembered how we play, & PSG had very few answers, or questions of their own to ask. It's not over yet by any stretch of the imagination, & PSG are a fearsome prospect, but so are we. Like I said, they've as much to worry about as we have, so as long as we continue where we left off, with a dash of luck hopefully we'll prevail.
Regardless, it was a match worthy of a Champions League Semi Final. I'm just relieved it went our way with the home leg still to come.