Let's split the difference.. he's 34 and at that age.. not everyone ages like Ferna did. When everyone is young, in their prime.. just losing 1/2 a second is all you need to be ineffective.
It happened to someone I love - Ayme Laporte too. And he willingly sacrificed his knee so that we could get the 2022 title and played injured. I will never forget that!
Sadly not everyone retires in their prime. So it happens to everyone and forces Pep to make painful decisions.
Ok, every player ages at some point.
Does that make Kompany shite? Or Fernandinho? How about KDB?
The abuse of players and even of Pep at times on this site, because of two bad months, has been pretty shocking to me.