Pep Guardiola - 2024/25

Status
Not open for further replies.
Stopped buying players who could keep the ball and thus the game, so it’s been basketball-football for the last two years. Like watching a great boxer suddenly decide to fight southpaw.
Yep. No-one will ever make me understand why, after winning the treble, we immediately made it our business to move away from what made us so successful and start signing players that couldn’t play that kind of football.
That summer, post-treble, sowed the seeds for where we are now.
 
we have 10 finals left, 9 finals left, 8 finals left etc, does this do any extra motivation for players?
 
De Zerbi

Alonso

Kompany???
De Zerbi who ended up 10th with Brighton then fell out with the board and walked off?

Alonso who’s 2 years into his career, not to mention he’s been courted by Madrid?

Kompany who’s inexperienced at the top level?
 
Iraola for me - played for New York City so will have some familiarity and friends within the CFG, plus I think the likes of Foden, Grealish, Haaland - and the fans - need to be reinvigorated by his more expressive, direct style of football.
Wow, no idea he was that Iraola. Didn't realize how quickly he kicked off his managing career.
 
Iraola for me - played for New York City so will have some familiarity and friends within the CFG, plus I think the likes of Foden, Grealish, Haaland - and the fans - need to be reinvigorated by his more expressive, direct style of football.
The guy is good and has potential, but has never managed a top top club before. Do you really want to gamble on that?
 
It's not up to us to make that decision, it's up to the club. But if this bleeds into next season we can't keep him just because of what he's achieved for us in the past; he's clearly affected by something and he's the only one who can address it.

The last thing we need is a Wenger scenario developing.
The point is, as of now, if there is no one ideal to replace him, what do you do?

It really depends on how the board wants, do they want to keep being elite and fight for every trophies, or do they settle for a top-4 fight every year and gamble on a young coach?

If trophies are the target, then the options are very few.
 
For that kind of money you’d expect numerous league titles, FA Cups, League Cups and the odd European Cup. Eh? Oh…
You also don't expect a scrap for top 5 when you have a world class squad. I'll give him a pass this season for the injuries, but the injuries plus his stubbornness and poor man management are why we are where we are. Those wages are also for digging us out of situations like this, but it's the same uninspiring performances and tactics while only playing one game a week.
 
It isn’t Pep’s fault that Savinho missed a sitter, that Doku can’t cross, Ortega gets beat by a free kick on his side or Khusanov knees one into his own net. The performance in general wasn’t that bad. The team is run into the ground and lack confidence. Like I mentioned the core of this squad is either injured or playing shit. What other options have we got to play in midfield or defence
So essentially you're saying that Txiki massively overpaid for the team we put out today. In that case, thank god he's leaving.

Oh and why not give O'Reilly a game?
 
By recent standards this season has been crap, but then I think of what we were like when Alan Ball was in charge and that brings things into perspective for me. The standards have been so high. 4 in a row etc. Naturally there's going to be a drop off for various reasons. Injuries, player fatigue, new signings not working out etc etc.

Looking at what we've got in our squad right now we are a few players short. We need more pace in defence. Particularly at right and left back. We need more creativity in midfield. We need Rodri back. Hopefully he can get back to his best.

We need to move on some of the treble winners that are either past it or now stale and need a new challenge.

Pep needs to evolve too and assemble a new hungry squad that's fit to challenge in a more sustained way next season otherwise it may be time for a revolution.
 
They cost enough. Maybe Txiki is to blame. I am looking forward to seeing how Viana does.

Pep's coaching has to take some blame, but in my opinion Txiki should have left after the treble for a new DOF to rebuild then.

It needed fresh eyes which has been been proven in the poor recruitment of the last few windows.
 
Hard to blame the manager when it's individual defensive errors costing us.

But our #1 problem is..
We can't play KDB every game,
we can't play Bernardo every game,
and we refuse to play Nunes every game,
when they're the most creative players on the team!

View attachment 149880
Hard to blame? Hes the manager, the book stops with him in terms of results. He is responsible for the results and performance levels...I bet you weren't saying it's hard to praise him during the success we've had under him.

His tactics, set up, substitutions have been abysmal all season and not to mention some of the utter drivel he's coming out with in interviews and press conferences. He appears rattled and completely clueless as to how to solve this.

He's never had to deal with a downturn like this during his managerial career and that is becoming more and more apparent. To say its hard to blame him is absolute nonsense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top