Player Topic: Nicolas Otamendi (2015/16)

Status
Not open for further replies.
He's only got 1 straight red and 1 yellow/red in his entire career. He goes off his feet, but he's good at it.
Yes, but you've got to remember that the ref at Palace will be Mike Jones. Whether or not Otamendi is "good at it" becomes irrelevant when the ref is incompetent - remember Sergio's booking at Southampton last year by the same ref?
 
Yes, but you've got to remember that the ref at Palace will be Mike Jones. Whether or not Otamendi is "good at it" becomes irrelevant when the ref is incompetent - remember Sergio's booking at Southampton last year by the same ref?

And I'm sure he's never come across an incompetent referee before...
 
Watched that penalty decision about 10 times and there's no way the ball could take that trajectory and the man falling like that unless he done a classic catching the ground first and then partially hitting the ball. If Otamendi catches him and takes none of the ball, then the trajectory of the ball is confusing. Still not entirely sure what to make of it.


Edit: I'm pretty sure that Otamendi got the ball and the Mexican lad kicked his boot and turned into Tom Daley in the process. A slow motion would confirm it or make me out a pillock.
 
Watched that penalty decision about 10 times and there's no way the ball could take that trajectory and the man falling like that unless he done a classic catching the ground first and then partially hitting the ball. If Otamendi catches him and takes none of the ball, then the trajectory of the ball is confusing. Still not entirely sure what to make of it.

If you leg it forward forty yards then leg it back & jump at someone from behind, with both feet off the ground, you deserve a red card, penalty & dropping imo. Shocking.

Otamendi last night, was like Darren Huckerby playing centre back. His positioning was as bad as anything I've ever seen. His distribution of any pass over 10 yards must have been about 10% & he got absolutely bitched by fucking Chicarito in the air at one point. And he was wearing pink fucking boots.

If he ever has a game like that for City, it will be his last.
 
If you leg it forward forty yards then leg it back & jump at someone from behind, with both feet off the ground, you deserve a red card, penalty & dropping imo. Shocking.

Otamendi last night, was like Darren Huckerby playing centre back. His positioning was as bad as anything I've ever seen. His distribution of any pass over 10 yards must have been about 10% & he got absolutely bitched by fucking Chicarito in the air at one point. And he was wearing pink fucking boots.

If he ever has a game like that for City, it will be his last.

Lol, I never seen the game, just commenting on the penalty and he didn't jump two footed at the player, he hookd one leg round and its an eye Boggler. A slow motion shot would confirm 100% what happened there but for the rest of the game, I'll take your word, let's hope its first game rustiness ( if that was his first game back after the summer )
 
Lol, I never seen the game, just commenting on the penalty and he didn't jump two footed at the player, he hookd one leg round and its an eye Boggler. A slow motion shot would confirm 100% what happened there but for the rest of the game, I'll take your word, let's hope its first game rustiness ( if that was his first game back after the summer )

If Phil Jones did that to Aguero & we didn't get a pen, we'd go fucking apeshit.

Rojo was also wearing pink boots & rightly got subbed.
 
Watched that penalty decision about 10 times and there's no way the ball could take that trajectory and the man falling like that unless he done a classic catching the ground first and then partially hitting the ball. If Otamendi catches him and takes none of the ball, then the trajectory of the ball is confusing. Still not entirely sure what to make of it.


Edit: I'm pretty sure that Otamendi got the ball and the Mexican lad kicked his boot and turned into Tom Daley in the process. A slow motion would confirm it or make me out a pillock.

Lucky not to get a red. Going to ground from behind and denied a clear goal scoring opportunity.

Similar to Danny Rose on Dzeko.
 
If Phil Jones did that to Aguero & we didn't get a pen, we'd go fucking apeshit.

Rojo was also wearing pink boots & rightly got subbed.

Need to see it in slow motion but ye, if he did catch the man first 100%, we would be pissed if it was on Aguero but if he got the ball, which I think he did ( may very well be wrong ) then I'd have no real complaints.

What's wrong with a classic pair of black copa Americas man!
 
Lucky not to get a red. Going to ground from behind and denied a clear goal scoring opportunity.

Similar to Danny Rose on Dzeko.

Ye, the ref gave a pen so it should have been a red by the letter of their law, any computer whizz, who can slow it down so we can know once and for all?
 
If you leg it forward forty yards then leg it back & jump at someone from behind, with both feet off the ground, you deserve a red card, penalty & dropping imo. Shocking.

Otamendi last night, was like Darren Huckerby playing centre back. His positioning was as bad as anything I've ever seen. His distribution of any pass over 10 yards must have been about 10% & he got absolutely bitched by fucking Chicarito in the air at one point. And he was wearing pink fucking boots.

If he ever has a game like that for City, it will be his last.

yeah i'm sure the club will consult you if they will play him or not again if he will have a bad game....you may tell them that we have WC players like denayer on loan who is head and shoulders over a shit otamendi....you just seems desperate for him to fail just to say you was right about the eds boys...god and please let's just not degenerate this into a further pointless conversation about it. if you agreed with me good if not good too
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.