Player topic: Sergio Aguero (2014/15)

[gordondaviesmoustache]

Re: Sergio Aguero

So you will know that isolated LCL rupture is unusual and associated with ACL and PCL tear....which is my fear.
To try and pick an isolated LCL clinically is difficult for Orthopaedic Consultants, so to expect a junior doc to do so is expecting a lot. As you know a knee can appear stable immediately after an injury due to swelling rendering the anterior draw test, Lachmanns and pivot shift test useless. We won't know for sure until he has had an MRI and anything prior to this is pure conjecture.

If there's one thing I cannot abide it's people who gratuitously use fancy words in order to demonstrate to a wider audience just how intelligent they are. It reeks of insecurity.

Which words don't you understand?

Very few.

 

[burnley blue mcfc]

Re: Sergio Aguero

Daily Mirror crying injury not as bad as feared. Could be back in a month.

Corrected for you.

Quality mate pmsl

 

[Ajay]

Re: Sergio Aguero

I have an idea, radical it may be, even absurd, but its just an idea....

Why dont we wait for the club to tell us what is happening?

Or maybe just wait for confirmation that he is acttually out for at least 4 weeks maybe 6 maximum dependent on treatment :)

 

[Len Rum]

Re: Sergio Aguero

Yeah. Me too. How often have you seen a postero lateral corner injury?

With a complete lateral collateral rupture (which they usually are as you well know) most of the time. They are usually missed by junior docs in casualty in my experience and require delayed reconstruction.

So you will know that isolated LCL rupture is unusual and associated with ACL and PCL tear....which is my fear.
To try and pick an isolated LCL clinically is difficult for Orthopaedic Consultants, so to expect a junior doc to do so is expecting a lot. As you know a knee can appear stable immediately after an injury due to swelling rendering the anterior draw test, Lachmanns and pivot shift test useless. We won't know for sure until he has had an MRI and anything prior to this is pure conjecture.

I thought you'd left a while ago.

 

[George Hannah]

Re: Sergio Aguero

I have an idea, radical it may be, even absurd, but its just an idea....

Why dont we wait for the club to tell us what is happening?

Or maybe just wait for confirmation that he is acttually out for at least 4 weeks maybe 6 maximum dependent on treatment :)

Ajay, good to see your post but I think the longer we wait for an official pronouncement the more likely it is that they don't want a downer on the day of the big opening.

 

[Burtonblue]

Re: Sergio Aguero

With a complete lateral collateral rupture (which they usually are as you well know) most of the time. They are usually missed by junior docs in casualty in my experience and require delayed reconstruction.

So you will know that isolated LCL rupture is unusual and associated with ACL and PCL tear....which is my fear.
To try and pick an isolated LCL clinically is difficult for Orthopaedic Consultants, so to expect a junior doc to do so is expecting a lot. As you know a knee can appear stable immediately after an injury due to swelling rendering the anterior draw test, Lachmanns and pivot shift test useless. We won't know for sure until he has had an MRI and anything prior to this is pure conjecture.

If there's one thing I cannot abide it's people who gratuitously use fancy words in order to demonstrate to a wider audience just how intelligent they are. It reeks of insecurity.

Not the case here. It just happens to be what these things in your knees happen to be called. They are not fancy words, just terms.
Difficult to describe otherwise...
Apologies if some find this insulting or attempting to make myself look intelligent as just not the intention. It's what I do and have some expertise in....

 

[TCIB]

Re: Sergio Aguero

I have an idea, radical it may be, even absurd, but its just an idea....

Why dont we wait for the club to tell us what is happening?

Or maybe just wait for confirmation that he is acttually out for at least 4 weeks maybe 6 maximum dependent on treatment :)

You take your sound and sensible idea and get the hell out of here ajay :-D

 

[adrianr]

Re: Sergio Aguero

With a complete lateral collateral rupture (which they usually are as you well know) most of the time. They are usually missed by junior docs in casualty in my experience and require delayed reconstruction.

So you will know that isolated LCL rupture is unusual and associated with ACL and PCL tear....which is my fear.
To try and pick an isolated LCL clinically is difficult for Orthopaedic Consultants, so to expect a junior doc to do so is expecting a lot. As you know a knee can appear stable immediately after an injury due to swelling rendering the anterior draw test, Lachmanns and pivot shift test useless. We won't know for sure until he has had an MRI and anything prior to this is pure conjecture.

If there's one thing I cannot abide it's people who gratuitously use fancy words in order to demonstrate to a wider audience just how intelligent they are. It reeks of insecurity.

Arf.

(Too fancy?)

 

[Prestwich_Blue]

Re: Sergio Aguero

So you will know that isolated LCL rupture is unusual and associated with ACL and PCL tear....which is my fear.
To try and pick an isolated LCL clinically is difficult for Orthopaedic Consultants, so to expect a junior doc to do so is expecting a lot. As you know a knee can appear stable immediately after an injury due to swelling rendering the anterior draw test, Lachmanns and pivot shift test useless. We won't know for sure until he has had an MRI and anything prior to this is pure conjecture.

If there's one thing I cannot abide it's people who gratuitously use fancy words in order to demonstrate to a wider audience just how intelligent they are. It reeks of insecurity.

Which words don't you understand?

I think you're the one who's hard of understanding. I'll tell you when he'll be playing again; when the fourth official holds up his board with a green '16' on it. But when that will be, none of us know until we hear it from the club.

You've posted a load of pseudo-scientific crap assuring us it's an ACL then telling us no one knows and it's all speculation. It might or might not be an ACL but, sure as hell, you have no more idea than me or anyone else. So can I respectfully suggest you STFU.

You signed up 5 years ago and in that time we've qualified for the CL for the first time, won two PL titles, the FA and League cups but you've not seen fit to comment on any of these things. Yet as soon as Aguero, in the form of his life, has a potentially serious injury you're giving it large on here. You really can't complain if you're getting some stick.

 

[Ray78]

Re: Sergio Aguero

I have an idea, radical it may be, even absurd, but its just an idea....

Why dont we wait for the club to tell us what is happening?

Or maybe just wait for confirmation that he is acttually out for at least 4 weeks maybe 6 maximum dependent on treatment :)

Too sensible.