Player Topic: Vincent Kompany (2015/16)

Status
Not open for further replies.
We'll have to sell Aguero as well then for the same reason.

no , because Aguero's injuries are mostly impact injuries , he got clattered by Jagielka last season and missed 8 weeks and Dann chopped his legs from behind and hes missed another 6 weeks , Kun needs more protection from officials. VK's injuries a re ALL muscle injuries , that is the concern
 
no , because Aguero's injuries are mostly impact injuries , he got clattered by Jagielka last season and missed 8 weeks and Dann chopped his legs from behind and hes missed another 6 weeks , Kun needs more protection from officials. VK's injuries a re ALL muscle injuries , that is the concern
Indeed. In addition, we can deal with absences from Aguero and SIlva as they are 'impact' players and we should have reasonable back-up. Changing the back four every month is, by contrast, highly disruptive.
 
The first post I responded to jimmygrimble. Whilst not mentioning selling him directly, it's hard to read anything else into it other than getting rid.

at no stage have i said get rid of Vinnie , he should be used more sparingly and players who can stay fit like otto & mangala and eventually Denayer can develop , Vinny is nearly 30 , any club who want to win titles would be looking for a successor , but Vk will still have a massive influence at the club , dont start twisting my comments and misrepresenting what i put in my posts.
 
no , because Aguero's injuries are mostly impact injuries , he got clattered by Jagielka last season and missed 8 weeks and Dann chopped his legs from behind and hes missed another 6 weeks , Kun needs more protection from officials. VK's injuries a re ALL muscle injuries , that is the concern
Except he missed just 4 weeks last season and did play against West Ham seven days after Dann chopped his legs.
 
at no stage have i said get rid of Vinnie , he should be used more sparingly and players who can stay fit like otto & mangala and eventually Denayer can develop , Vinny is nearly 30 , any club who want to win titles would be looking for a successor , but Vk will still have a massive influence at the club , dont start twisting my comments and misrepresenting what i put in my posts.
It's not twisting your comments mate, it's how I read your first post. Using him sparingly and managing his game time is a perfectly reasonable stance to take and one I would tend to agree with going forward.
 
Indeed. In addition, we can deal with absences from Aguero and SIlva as they are 'impact' players and we should have reasonable back-up. Changing the back four every month is, by contrast, highly disruptive.
Yet we've been known to change the back four on a sometimes weekly basis for no reason whatsoever over the last 18 months or so.
 
no , because Aguero's injuries are mostly impact injuries , he got clattered by Jagielka last season and missed 8 weeks and Dann chopped his legs from behind and hes missed another 6 weeks , Kun needs more protection from officials. VK's injuries a re ALL muscle injuries , that is the concern
You are aware that Aguero has currently missed the last month through a hamstring injury sustained running and over reaching for a football on international duty? That's not an impact injury. Neither was his injury vs Arsenal December 2013, or Everton away 2014. Aguero suffers more muscle injuries than most so don't talk wet.

This link should help your poor memory. http://www.theguardian.com/football/2014/dec/07/sergio-aguero-injury-problems-manchester-city
 
if you have got an alternative opinion , state your case and have a sensible debate , i have no criticism of vinny's playing ability or leadership qualities or what he has achieved for the club , but he can't stay fit , do you seriously believe his injury problems will improve with age ?

My option is to play Vinnie when fit. Why? Because he's a really strong captain and arguably one of our best two central defenders. His injuries haven't reached the stage where I would relegate him to a second stringer when he is available to play.

His situation is little different from Kun, despite attempts to argue otherwise. We persevere with these guys because they offer such a lot when they are playing.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.