Excellent post
I have a lot of agreement with this post - even though it is dealing with a different aspect of 'management arrangements' to what
@Saddleworth2 and myself have mentioned and are experienced in.
We are essentially commenting on 'once the scope and intended outcomes/delivery' etc. are established - how a change programme should be managed.
But - you raise an excellent point - because before you get too far into implementation planning you need to decide the outcomes to be delivered.
What May should have done - right up front is an 'options appraisal' and I would guess that of (let's say) 10 options that would have been considered then only 3 or 4 would have been short-listed and none of those would have been the option of No-Deal and perhaps also not the deal that has been achieved.
The BRINO option would have certainly been on the short-list - as would Norway and others that reflect close-alignment. The 'contingency' of Remaining would have been kept alive as well.
And - again you are right - if we had achieved for example
@Mëtal Bikër 's desire for an EFTA solution - then the majority of people would have been satisfied and the extremists on both sides would have been left to whinge. There may have been some residual 'rumblings' - but this would have been ignored and the populace would have moved on.
I certainly would have been happy - in fact I would have expressed myself as being delighted. Notwithstanding that I am far more delighted with the actual outcome.
I come from the starting point of never thinking that we would leave - and then (even worse) in 2017-2019 thinking that we were going to end up in May's fucked up unfettered backstop.
I would have taken an EFTA arrangement in an heartbeat back in the dark days
You are indeed - spot on
The entire episode has been a series of fuckups and incompetence due to being driven and affected by self-interest groups.
The end result - what we have now - feels like some perverse game of 'pass the parcel' - with this deal being the last one to get a seat - pure luck.