robin van persie (continued)

[kompany10]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

NO! ... World class player but not the right age and injury record, no sell on value.

What does sell on value have to do with you?

WOuld you rather we sold Kun aged 26 for a fuck load or kept him til he was 32 with a smaller value?

its a waste of money, the only way we are goin to get him if we pay 20million for him. we should be buying players who are able to form part of our squad for 4/years not 1 or 2. Big no no!

 

[Blue Smarties]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

Meh, take him or leave him.

 

[WEMBLEY76]

Should we sign van persie yes or no

Have to say yes,but at same time,can see Dzeko going and like him too....
Difficult decisions all round,regarding the price if Mancini wants him we have to pay and if our Bosnian is Edin out the door,need to get a fair price as he will get better....

 

[maps]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

YASS

 

[spacecadet]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

Yes

 

[Eags]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

I say yes, on the following basis.

Hart

Zab/Micah Vinnie Lescott Clichy

Yaya

Silva Tevez Nasri

Aguero RVP

 

[BibbyBlue85]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

Without hesitation yes

 

[waspish]

Should we sign van persie yes or no

Yes let's sign everyone

 

[r.soleofsalford]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

NO! ... World class player but not the right age and injury record, no sell on value.

What does sell on value have to do with you?

WOuld you rather we sold Kun aged 26 for a fuck load or kept him til he was 32 with a smaller value?

sell on value should concern us all, just because our owner has vast wealth doesnt mean he`s going to spunk it out stupidly.

kun aguero was in fact 24 on 2nd june cost to city of £35 mil at the age of 23
van persie 29 on 6th august. potential cost to city of £20 to £25 mil

if they both stayed till 31

as a financial wizz kid i`ll let you do the maths

and as your a financial wizz i a bit shocked by your cavalier attitude to the sheikh`s money :)

 

[Outlaw]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

No

 

[kp220]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

Yes

 

[kompany10]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

NO! ... World class player but not the right age and injury record, no sell on value.

What does sell on value have to do with you?

WOuld you rather we sold Kun aged 26 for a fuck load or kept him til he was 32 with a smaller value?

sell on value should concern us all, just because our owner has vast wealth doesnt mean he`s going to spunk it out stupidly.

kun aguero was in fact 24 on 2nd june cost to city of £35 mil at the age of 23
van persie 29 on 6th august. potential cost to city of £20 to £25 mil

if they both stayed till 31

as a financial wizz kid i`ll let you do the maths

and as your a financial wizz i a bit shocked by your attitude to money :)

thats what i wanetd to say but couldnt put it in words. thanks mate.

 

[TonyM]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

Is there going to be a tally at some point? I'm too lazy.

 

[SWP's back]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

NO! ... World class player but not the right age and injury record, no sell on value.

What does sell on value have to do with you?

WOuld you rather we sold Kun aged 26 for a fuck load or kept him til he was 32 with a smaller value?

its a waste of money, the only way we are goin to get him if we pay 20million for him. we should be buying players who are able to form part of our squad for 4/years not 1 or 2. Big no no!

4 years takes him to 33.

How old was Drogba when he just won Chelsea the CL. How old was Sheringham when he did the same for Utd?

 

[Comrade Buka]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

Absolutely no.

 

[kompany10]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

What does sell on value have to do with you?

WOuld you rather we sold Kun aged 26 for a fuck load or kept him til he was 32 with a smaller value?

its a waste of money, the only way we are goin to get him if we pay 20million for him. we should be buying players who are able to form part of our squad for 4/years not 1 or 2. Big no no!

4 years takes him to 33.

How old was Drogba when he just won Chelsea the CL. How old was Sheringham when he did the same for Utd?

completly different situation and players. compare their injury records.

 

[SWP's back]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

NO! ... World class player but not the right age and injury record, no sell on value.

What does sell on value have to do with you?

WOuld you rather we sold Kun aged 26 for a fuck load or kept him til he was 32 with a smaller value?

sell on value should concern us all, just because our owner has vast wealth doesnt mean he`s going to spunk it out stupidly.

kun aguero was in fact 24 on 2nd june cost to city of £35 mil at the age of 23
van persie 29 on 6th august. potential cost to city of £20 to £25 mil

if they both stayed till 31

as a financial wizz kid i`ll let you do the maths

and as your a financial wizz i a bit shocked by your cavalier attitude to the sheikh`s money :)

If the Sheik is happy to spend it then who are we to question it? Winning the CL would add an extra £50m to the coffers. Would RVP give us a better chance of doing that than Dzeko I think yes. So does Mancini.

Would we be able to sell Dzeko and buy RVP for little or no net spend? Yes. Therefore the cost argument has just fallen away. Being a whizzkid allowed me to see 2 steps ahead. ;-)

 

[Le Havre Oswald]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

Yes

 

[SWP's back]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

completly different situation and players. compare their injury records.

Well I keep reading how will we keep 4 strikers happy? I would suggest rotation would lessen the likelihood of injurys.

But what does it matter, you're a soothsayer.

 

[Sunny Coast Blue]

Re: Should we sign van persie yes or no

NO, although it would piss Wenger off so do it and play him in the physio suite.