Russian invasion of Ukraine

i would expect ukraine to lose a lot of troops because they are attacking, think someone on here said earlier in the war russia would loose 5 to every 1 ukrainian due to ukraine defensive positions ,think that was the "rule" of war, maybe not the rule but the expected level
Ukraine can’t afford to lose troops in a 5 to 1 ratio so that’s unlikely be part of their planning.

The Ukrainians appear to be serial problem solvers.
 
Ukraine can’t afford to lose troops in a 5 to 1 ratio so that’s unlikely be part of their planning.

The Ukrainians appear to be serial problem solvers.
I don't think those ratios are realistic in this case as :)
a) Ukraine are on their own ground
b) they have state of the art weapons
c) the Russians have proven to be tactically inept.
 
i would expect ukraine to lose a lot of troops because they are attacking, think someone on here said earlier in the war russia would loose 5 to every 1 ukrainian due to ukraine defensive positions ,think that was the "rule" of war, maybe not the rule but the expected level
I don't recognise the 5:1 figures from my time in the army. The generally accepted rule was that you needed a 3:1 superiority to attack any particular formation with the implicit assumption that you would win at the end (so be numerically superior at that point) so to lose 5 for every 1 of their wouldn't make sense.
 
I don't recognise the 5:1 figures from my time in the army. The generally accepted rule was that you needed a 3:1 superiority to attack any particular formation with the implicit assumption that you would win at the end (so be numerically superior at that point) so to lose 5 for every 1 of their wouldn't make sense.
Yeah 3:1 - but the Russian attempts to take back lost trenches ASAP is costing them big time. So too are RUssian blocking units wiping out anyone retreats just a little bit.
It really is bonkers. It's the Russians doing the Ukrainians assaults for them in slow motion.
 
Last edited:
Just tried to view the news on Al Jazeera, but it's just a blank screen, so must be blocked.

I always like to get the news/reports from different perspectives, rather than just from the spoon-fed Sky News!
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.