Scott Sinclair

[Lancet Fluke]

From Planetswans forum

He's not good enough for City. Simple as.

When Fulham were linked with him, I thought that could be a decent move for him. Will get plenty of game time under a good manager and amongst good players.

I'd prefer him to stay here if he signs his contract though.


Read more at <a class="postlink" href="http://forum.planetswans.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=125677#WpR5fwfsGx8uLwVg.99" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;">http://forum.planetswans.co.uk/viewtopi ... x8uLwVg.99</a>

Says everything. When a small club players are linked with big club, they usually talk about how they want so much money and he's worth that much. These guys dont seem to be bothered about him leaving and think he's not good enough. I also remember reading sunderland forum when henderson was linked with Liverpool and most wanted him sold for the money that was being talked about. Fans know their own players better than anyone

To be fair most of the posters on that Swansea site seem to be basing their "not good enough for City" opinion on the notion that we would be signing him to go into the first team as a regular starter which clearly wouldn't be the case. They seem to be under the same delusion as many City fans that we can have a squad of 30 top class players, all of equal ability with half of them rarely playing.

 

[BlueBilly]

Good Premier League player, not good enough for us. Adam Johnson is very frustrating, but he's twice the player Sinclair is.

 

[Matt Diablo]

Good Premier League player, not good enough for us. Adam Johnson is very frustrating, but he's twice the player Sinclair is.

as for the requirement of a winger needing pace I totally disagree

 

[DaveTheYid]

Lennon would be a good player for you guys but his price is £25mill.

 

[taconinja]

Lennon would be a good player for you guys but his price is £25mill.

Levy can go fuck himself with a rusty shovel... sideways. 25 million...

 

[oakiecokie]

Just to fan the flames Sinclair is a self confessed Man United supporter. They are his dream club to play for and the team he supports. Uh oh!

And ??

 

[hgblue]

Lennon would be a good player for you guys but his price is £25mill.

We're still trying to find the money to sell Adebayor to you.

 

[Lancet Fluke]

Good Premier League player, not good enough for us. Adam Johnson is very frustrating, but he's twice the player Sinclair is.

So you honestly think that we can now say that a "good Premier League player" is not good enough to be a squad player at City? Exactly what calibre of player do you expect us to have on the bench? We don't play with wingers regularly, so any winger we sign is going to be a squad player rather than a regular starter, but we need to still have wingers in the squad. Who do you think we should sign for that role?

 

[Tony101]

Good Premier League player, not good enough for us. Adam Johnson is very frustrating, but he's twice the player Sinclair is.

So you honestly think that we can now say that a "good Premier League player" is not good enough to be a squad player at City? Exactly what calibre of player do you expect us to have on the bench? We don't play with wingers regularly, so any winger we sign is going to be a squad player rather than a regular starter, but we need to still have wingers in the squad. Who do you think we should sign for that role?

Squad player should be able to compete for a place in the starting 11. i never get the idea that there has to be a set order. You have to have competition

 

[pudge]

Lennon would be a good player for you guys but his price is £25mill.

Levy wouldn't sell Lennon, it would throw the Falcao move into doubt. I heard he and Lennon are bessie mates.

But seriously DTY, your act is getting old now.