Vertonghen was also a yard or two inside the box, so if we’re being picky (which is the whole idea of VAR), then it should’ve been retaken.A further point on var, when Sergio had his penalty saved in the first leg, the keeper was off his line, it was shown on BT so the penalty should have been retaken.
Var doesn't seem to check on penalties taken which does seem a little strange seeing as the one at Spurs which if I'm honest I never thought was a penalty in the world of man, but once saved why was the goalkeeper position not checked along with the man who cleared the rebound just to ensure the laws of the game were adhered to as on Wednesday.PS Sergio was offside sadly.A further point on var, when Sergio had his penalty saved in the first leg, the keeper was off his line, it was shown on BT so the penalty should have been retaken.
Var doesn't seem to check on penalties taken which does seem a little strange seeing as the one at Spurs which if I'm honest I never thought was a penalty in the world of man, but once saved why was the goalkeeper position not checked along with the man who cleared the rebound just to ensure the laws of the game were adhered to as on Wednesday.PS Sergio was offside sadly.
I certainly couldn't tell from 109 but in pub after watching replay he certainly looked offside when ball struck Silva's foot.Sergio may quite possibly have been offside, but on what do you base that ? as they continue to refuse to show the official freeze frame with their pretty coloured lines on them, on which they "presumably" based the VAR call.You would have thought 2 days would have been long enough to get hold of one , (from somewhere !)
They always do show them, don't they ? to PROVE they got the decision right ?
i agree with what they showed, but the only image i've seen was fractionally before it reached Bernardo's left leg, and it hit his right leg, and Sergio was moving back towards becoming onside. If it was offside (quite possibly) why not show it like they normally doI certainly couldn't tell from 109 but in pub after watching replay he certainly looked offside when ball struck Silva's foot.
Sergio may quite possibly have been offside, but on what do you base that ? as they continue to refuse to show the official freeze frame with their pretty coloured lines on them, on which they "presumably" based the VAR call.You would have thought 2 days would have been long enough to get hold of one , (from somewhere !)
They always do show them, don't they ? to PROVE they got the decision right ?
I think this although very very close(so a harsh call to take) is offside.
I know this freeze frame is after the contact with Bernardos foot but isn't Aguero moving in from an offside position to get onside? Meaning further back from that he's more offside? This was easier to take, if both calls had been handled the same... mm offside is offside, advantage gained with the arm deliberate or not is handball.