Since he nearly cost us the league against QPR, I cant remember him having one game where I've thought he's a decent defender. Granted, for the most part of our title winning season he was pretty solid alongside Vinnie, but never at any point in his career have I ever thought he should be playing for a top club challenging for honours.
For a professional footballer the only word I can think of to describe him with the ball at his feet is 'tragic'.
The way we set up with a high line under Manuel now, more or less renders him utterly useless unless he's challenging for headers. He doesn't have any pace, he's hopeless with the ball at his feet and his passing is beyond awful.
The only player I would rather see leave the club is Garcia.
Biggest no ever from me.