Silva or Robinho?

[Armaan]

It's hard to compare. I think Robinho would be superb in our team now.

Silva might not look so great alongside, Benjani, Ireland and Vassell.

Exactly my point

 

[20sbc07]

It's hard to compare. I think Robinho would be superb in our team now.

Silva might not look so great alongside, Benjani, Ireland and Vassell.

Agreed.
I think Robinho would be amazing in the team, he just joined us at the wrong time.
I'd take him back in a second.

 

[TheSituation]

If Robinho was on the top of his game as consistently as Silva is it'd be Robinho for me, 06/07 at Real Madrid he was out of this world. But, he wasn't, and never will be, so Silva.

 

[Freestyler]

Silva.

didn't even have to think for a split second.

 

[twosips]

Easily Silva. EASILY.

 

[Ntini77]

Silva or Elano would've been a better topic.

 

[FantasyIreland]

Joke of a thread.

You are comparing a player who has integrity,passion and the ability to match with an egotistical spineless show pony who couldn't have give a fook about this club,ycnmiu.....

 

[moorsideblue]

although i would love for robinho to still be at the club, silva is the better player without a shadow of a doubt, IMO silva is the best player to have ever played for us

 

[Nerazzurri]

Robinho is lacking in tactical intelligence and decision making. On top of that he has poor workrate.

Silva needs to up his finishing and get some more assists. Brilliant player though.

 

[Love_Each_Day]

Robinho never worked half as hard trying to find space to recieve the ball and get us playing like Silva does for us now, shame as he had more than enough ability to do it. Both fantastically gifted but Silva has the heart to back it up.